The Best Yellowstone Season, According To Rotten Tomatoes

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

As far as TV in the 2020s goes, it's hard to find a show that has had a larger impact than "Yellowstone." What started as a somewhat inconspicuous Western TV series on an upper-tier cable channel turned into the biggest hit on television. It also transformed its creator into one of Hollywood's golden boys, with Taylor Sheridan having since developed an entire universe of "Yellowstone" TV shows (not to mention his other series, like "Tulsa King" and "Landman"). But when did the show that started it all hit its peak? What was the best of the best of "Yellowstone?"

The show, broadly speaking, centers on John Dutton (Kevin Coster), a sixth-generation homesteader who controls the largest contiguous ranch in the United States. His world is one of corrupt politicians and corporations, while the Dutton's ranch itself is in a constant state of conflict with its surrounding areas, including an expanding town, an Indigenous American reservation, and a national park.

"Yellowstone" premiered in 2018 and, though it may be hard to believe now, season 1 is actually "rotten" on Rotten Tomatoes with a 58% critical approval rating. In fact, "Yellowstone" was almost canceled after season 2, which is also hard to believe in retrospect. But it didn't take long for Sheridan to showcase his worth and for the show to prove its value, as season 3 changed the game.

With high highs and the saga of the Duttons really hitting its stride, "Yellowstone" season 3 carries a perfect 100% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The series called it quits after a somewhat rocky season 5, which had to contend with Costner's departure as John Dutton, but it was season that cemented the show's place in the broader cultural conversation. It was the water mark that would never be surpassed, critically speaking.

Season 3 of "Yellowstone" sees the Duttons having to protect their land from enemies both old and new, led by the ruthless Wall Street wiz Roarke (Josh Holloway). Along the way, John and the gang face threats like betrayals, bad blood, and lucrative business deals, forcing the formation of unexpected alliances in addition to undertaking dangerous, extreme measures to safeguard their legacy.

Notably, while season 3 is broadly considered the best overall season, it led into the "Yellowstone" season 4 premiere, "Half the Money," which is the highest-rated single episode of the show overall. It probably helped that season 3 aired in 2020 when the pandemic forced a lot of people to stay home and watch TV more than usual, which led to its viewership greatly expanding.

From that point on, though, it was a downhill ride for "Yellowstone." Every great show has a peak, and every great show has a valley. It's the nature of the beast. It probably didn't help that Sheridan had become extremely busy developing spin-offs such as "1883" and "1923," as well as other series like "Mayor of "Kingstown." His attention was pulled in many different directions. When season 3 was in the works, Sheridan was able to give it much more of his focus.

As for the future, this universe is still going strong. There are multiple different "Yellowstone" spin-offs, sequels, and prequels in the works. Some of those will stream on Paramount+, while "Y: Marshalls," starring Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton, will be airing on CBS. Whether or not any of these shows will be able to match the high water mark set by "Yellowstone" season 3 remains to be seen.

You can buy "Yellowstone: The Complete Series" on Blu-ray or DVD from Amazon.