The Good Place Ending

Michael Schur, the creator and showrunner of NBC’s ambitious philosophical comedy The Good Place, has never been shy about acknowledging the inspiration he found in ABC’s seminal sci-fi action drama Lost. Though the two shows, on the face of it, would seem to be wildly different, you can not only spot references to Lost in The Good Place, but Schur both consulted with Lost co-showrunner Damon Lindelof  early in the run of the comedy, and Lost writer Drew Goddard has directed a handful of episodes, including the pilot.

There’s one more place in which The Good Place needs to find some inspiration from Lost, though, and hopefully soon: it’s time for The Good Place to announce its end date.

This post contains major spoilers for all three seasons of The Good Place.

The Shape of Things to Come

Depending on how good your memory is, you may not remember the appropriately unique way in which ABC announced that Lost was wrapping up. The year was 2007, and Lost had gone through a roller-coaster of popularity through barely 3 seasons. The show’s first season, full of exciting mysteries, characters, and cliffhangers, won the Best Drama Emmy; the second season, however, didn’t even get a Best Drama Emmy nomination. By season three, ABC tried to mix things up with a six-episode kick-off that felt like a self-contained story meant to drum up excitement. But by the spring of 2007, the show hit a creative nadir: an episode whose trademark flashbacks were all about Jack Shephard (Matthew Fox) and his mysterious…tattoos.

That episode, the obnoxious “Stranger in a Strange Land”, and its largely negative reaction from critics and fans, is what led Lindelof and fellow showrunner Carlton Cuse to convince ABC to let them establish the endgame of Lost. Fans would still have to guess where the show was going, but knowing that there was somewhere the show could go was enormously relieving. So in May of 2007, ABC announced that it had renewed Lost for three more seasons, with the sixth being its last.

Lost announced its ending — and, to note, improved vastly in its final three 16-episode seasons because there was a sense of propulsion absent from much of its second and third seasons — because the show was spinning its wheels. On one hand, that is absolutely not the issue with The Good Place. I’ll note here that I still am a huge fan of Schur’s wildly distinctive comedy, which began with a heady enough premise: a woman named Eleanor Shellstrop (Kristen Bell) wakes up in an afterlife called The Good Place, and is terrified to realize that, through a clerical error, she has taken the place of another woman with the same name who was vastly more deserving of going to Heaven.

Over 39 episodes in three seasons (the third season concluded on January 24), The Good Place has burned through plot at a shocking rate, specifically after the first-season finale threw out a shocking twist. Eleanor and the oddball friends she’s made so far are actually in a version of the Bad Place designed to emulate the Good Place as a new form of torture. Their Good Place architect, Michael (Ted Danson), is actually a Bad Place demon overseeing the hell-is-other-people-style torture.

the good place season 2

A Roller Coaster of Plot

From that point, The Good Place felt like a different show, and an even more thrilling one. The show’s second season offered a major shift from its predecessor, and for the better — where the first season charted Eleanor’s shift towards goodness, the second season focused on how the literally demonic Michael could become a genuinely good and caring character. Danson, of course, sold the shift incredibly, but he was aided by scripts that laughed in the face of normal TV-storytelling progress. As Schur has noted in interviews, in another writer’s hands, the first season cliffhanger wouldn’t have been Eleanor realizing she’s in the Bad Place. Instead, the first season might have ended with her admission that she doesn’t belong in the Good Place at all, an event that takes place roughly halfway through the first season. That was a sign of things to come.

In the second season’s third episode, “Dance Dance Resolution”, the show began its fast burn. The previous season ended not just with Eleanor realizing she was in the Bad Place, but with Michael erasing her memories, as well as the memories of her friends Chidi (William Jackson Harper), Tahani (Jameela Jamil) and Jason (Manny Jacinto), and restarting his Bad Place experiment. But by “Dance Dance Resolution,” it became clear that in every reset of the experiment, Eleanor or one of her friends would realize what was truly going on, and Michael would have to reset things again so that his own Bad Place boss wouldn’t suspect anything was wrong. So Michael reset the experiment more than 800 times, all in the span of one 22-minute episode.

Resetting things is something The Good Place has done a lot lately. Here’s a few examples (with heavy third-season spoilers, so consider yourself warned): Michael and Janet (D’Arcy Carden), his partner/best friend/sidekick who’s also an omniscient being who holds all knowledge of the universe while not being human or robot herself, monitor Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, and Jason on Earth after they’ve been allowed to restart their lives from the moment when they had previously died. Michael and Janet, fearing the four humans are reverting back to their old ways, nudge Chidi and Simone, a neuroscientist at a Sydney, Australia-based university, to create a joint study researching near-death experiences and how it changes people’s morality, thus bringing the four humans back together. For a year, Michael and Janet monitor the humans, until they accidentally reveal themselves and inform the four humans of what’s really going on.

They then band together as a self-pronounced “Soul Squad” to make other people get better so they can get into The Good Place, eventually letting Michael bring them to meet the one person who best represents every possible great decision a human could make. They then learn that even though this character lives his life the best way possible, the most humane way possible, even he can’t get into the Good Place. So Michael decides to ferret out who within the Bad Place must be manipulating the points system, only to shift his mindset and appeal to the Judge (Maya Rudolph, in a recurring role) that the problem is that the points system combined with modern life makes it too hard for anyone to get into the Good Place. The Judge works with Michael and Bad Place emissary Shawn (Marc Evan Jackson) to create a new Good Place/Bad Place experiment, but with four new humans. Until it becomes clear that Shawn has chosen four humans who all have particular relevance to our four human heroes. With this, Chidi decides to have his own mind wiped to eliminate any conflicts of ethical interest between himself and his friends.

Continue Reading The Good Place and Lost >>

Pages: 1 2Next page

Cool Posts From Around the Web: