Why Deadwood Was Canceled – Here's What We Know
"Deadwood" ran from 2004 to 2006 on HBO, and during that time, it constantly reminded viewers that death was just around the corner. In the Old West town of Deadwood, located in the South Dakota territory, residents were just as likely to die from rogue kidney stones as they were in a classic cowboy gunfight. Death was inevitable, and even sometimes comical. Yet it still came as a surprise when the show itself was killed off after three acclaimed seasons.
The series follows the exploits of settlers in Deadwood, including some real-life historical figures. Chief among them are begrudging lawman Seth Bullock (Timothy Olyphant) and foul-mouthed Gem Saloon owner Al Swearengen (Ian McShane). "Deadwood" is beloved for plenty of good reasons, including its compelling ensemble cast and creator-writer David Milch's expletive-riddled, near-Shakespearean scripts.
A Complicated Cancelation
15 years after the series' last episodes aired, stories about its cancelation still differ. By all accounts, the series was planned for at least four seasons. Star Olyphant has publicly worried that he derailed the show after buying a house based on a raise that hadn't been completely finalized yet. According to an interview Olyphant did with Rolling Stone, Milch also called Olyphant to tell him the show was over, but may have been premature. Olyphant admitted that "it was a bit of a grass fire, if you will, that became difficult for the two sides to then walk back."
In the years since its abrupt cancellation, several other clear-cut reasons for the series' cancellation have emerged. According to several sources, including Vulture, "Deadwood" came to an unexpected end after its third season due to "a financial dispute between HBO and co-producer Paramount." Vulture further cites Milch's unorthodox approach to showrunning and a decline in ratings as reasons the network chose not to renew the series for an anticipated fourth season.
Closure Came Later
One thing is for certain: the original run of "Deadwood" ends without closure. In the show's last episode, "Tell Him Something Pretty," Al kills one sex worker to spare another, and villainous businessman George Hearst (Gerald McRaney) leaves town victorious, keeping the story open for the future. Several characters' arcs go largely unresolved, and there's plenty of ground left to cover.
Thankfully, "Deadwood" finally received the closure it deserved in the form of a feature-length HBO movie in 2019, one that had been years in the making. "Deadwood: The Movie" sees the return of Bullock and Swearengen, along with Calamity Jane (Robin Weigert), Doc Cochran (Brad Dourif), and plenty of other "Deadwood" favorites. The film picks up with South Dakota on the precipice of statehood in 1889, with Hearst returning as a central villain, and it serves as an ending in every way possible. "Deadwood: The Movie" provides a heartfelt, bittersweet on-screen conclusion that seems to be the last we'll see of this town of lovable delinquents.
"Deadwood" and "Deadwood: The Movie" are currently available on HBO and HBO Max.