The Most Frustrating Horror Movie Snubs In Oscars History

Each year Hollywood unites around a peculiar tradition as actors, filmmakers, and members of the press gather for a reading of the highly-anticipated Oscar nominations. This list is always met with excitement, but recent years have seen plans for the annual awards ceremony stir up an increasing amount of controversy. Each new rundown of honorees sparks the inevitable discussion of filmmakers and performers overlooked by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the dissection of these "Oscar snubs" becoming the norm rather than the exception.

Academy leaders have attempted to combat these complaints by diversifying the roster of industry voters and expanding the best picture category to allow for up to 10 entries. However, the institution has a long history of ignoring horror movies and performances that should have been nominated, and each year's announcements bring with them increasingly frustrating snubs. 

Mia Goth recently stated she believes these continued omissions are "very political" and that "a shift should take place if they wanted to engage with the wider public." Ignored for her much-praised performance in Ti West's "Pearl," she joins a growing list — including Toni Collette, Lupita Nyong'o, and Jordan Peele's third film, "Nope" — of talent shut out of every category. However aggravating these snubs may be, they are far from the only horror films to be overlooked by the Academy. The following are 14 films definitely worthy of Oscar love that were left out in the cold.

One of the most celebrated horror films of all time was completely ignored by the Academy and almost universally disregarded upon its release. John Carpenter's "The Thing" follows a group of U.S. researchers stationed in Antarctica who are attacked by a shape-shifting alien hiding in plain sight. The claustrophobic movie has now become known for jaw-dropping special effects sequences, wickedly dry humor, and a palpable feeling of paranoia that carries through to its ambiguous ending. Carpenter's first studio feature, "The Thing" was skewered by critics and avoided by audiences likely due to the success of both "ET" and "Poltergeist," released just weeks earlier, saturating the market for horror and alien fare.

Though frequently listed among the famed director's best outings, Carpenter notes that the film's initial failure nearly tanked his own career. In an interview with Variety, he remembered, "It was a hated, cursed movie for a very long time. And I was out of work and feeling pretty bleak." In 2019 Carpenter was awarded the French Directors' Guild Carrosse d'Or Award at the Cannes Film Festival after a screening of "The Thing," now considered a masterpiece. Though he has never been recognized by the Academy, Carpenter names this frozen horror and its nihilistic ending as one of the entries in his long catalog of which he's most proud.

Four years before Michael Myers first stalked babysitters, a mysterious killer named Billy lurked in the shadows of a snowy sorority house. Bob Clark's "Black Christmas" follows Jess (Olivia Hussey) and her sorority sisters as they fend off attacks from a stealthy killer making lewd phone calls from the attic. The groundbreaking film is recognized as a proto-slasher and likely inspired John Carpenter's debut effort, "Halloween." Beyond this influential reputation, "Black Christmas" is a phenomenal and terrifying film in its own right. Clark treats his young characters like adults and shows Final Girl Jess resisting repeated proposals from her domineering boyfriend and planning to have an abortion, a plotline still controversial nearly 50 years later.

"Black Christmas" perfectly blends holiday imagery and mounting dread, but Clark's impressive restraint is what propels the film to new levels of terror. Experimenting with a unique point of view, Clark explained, "I wanted to do something I didn't think had been done before which is to play my killer as a subliminal character. You never see him except as a shadow or one other time. Otherwise, he is the camera." Clark's deft handling of this cinematic device sparked a slasher craze still raging, and his refusal to show the killer leads to one of the most haunting conclusions in horror history.

Adaptations of Stephen King novels tend to be a mixed bag. For every "The Shawshank Redemption," there's a "Dreamcatcher;" for every "Carrie," a "Maximum Overdrive." Stories from the Master of Horror's vast catalog can be tricky to translate to the big screen, but few novels are as challenging as "Doctor Sleep." A sequel to King's third book, "The Shining," the story hones in on an adult Danny Torrance decades after escaping the sinister Overlook Hotel as a child. Any adaptation of this novel would also be a sequel to Stanley Kubrick's film "The Shining,” considered one of the greatest horror films of all time. Kubrick's version of the story differs wildly from the original novel and King famously hates it. That's a lot for any filmmaker to contend with.

Fresh off a successful adaptation of "Gerald's Game," a novel long thought to be unfilmable, Mike Flanagan decided to try his hand at the challenging text. Faithfully adapting the first half of the novel, Flanagan veers towards Kubrick's film in the final act and sets his climactic battle in the abandoned (but still standing) Overlook Hotel. By marrying two respected but disparate stories into a cohesive narrative, Flanagan seemingly achieved the impossible and even managed to get King on board with his changes. The world-famous author told EW, "I read the script very, very carefully and I said to myself, 'Everything that I ever disliked about the Kubrick version of "The Shining "is redeemed for me here.'"

Few films of any genre are lucky enough to feature one Oscar-worthy performance, and only the rarest cinematic gems are graced with two. The French horror film "Inside" from writing-directing team Alexandre Bustillo and Julien Maury boasts a pair of breathtaking performances from Béatrice Dalle and Alysson Paradis as women fighting to the death over an unborn child. Set on Christmas Eve, pregnant widow Sarah (Paradis) is preparing to give birth early the next morning when she's attacked by a mysterious Woman (Dalle) determined to steal her baby. Called the "crown jewel of the new wave of extreme French horror films” by Bloody Disgusting, "Inside" delivers an unrelenting nightmare filled with grisly violence and intense gore.

Dressed in old-fashioned black and toting a pair of steel scissors, Dalle gives the showier performance as the deranged Woman, but the film is grounded by an exceptional turn as reluctant mother-to-be Paradis, whose dread at the impending birth is only matched by her 11th-hour determination to save her child's life. Both actresses were honored with Fangoria Chainsaw Awards for their brilliant work but were sadly overlooked at the Oscars. No doubt, the extreme nature of the film scared away Academy voters, creating a textbook example of award-worthy performances ignored due to intense subject matter.

Though the Academy has a history of spurning horror-film performances, when they do honor genre actors, it's often for playing charismatic villains. Kathy Bates won a best actress Oscar for her disturbing portrayal of a crazed fan in "Misery" and Anthony Hopkins took home the best actor statuette when "The Silence of the Lambs" swept the Big Five awards at the 1992 ceremony. However, one of horror's most thrilling baddies never achieved this distinction. After more sensitive roles in "Newsies" and "Little Women," Christian Bale picked up an ax to portray yuppy serial killer Patrick Bateman, a narcissistic investment banker by day and bloodthirsty misogynist by night in Mary Harron's adaptation of the ultra-violent satire "American Psycho" by Bret Easton Ellis.

Bale dug into the role with a ferocious intensity, rarely breaking character, and working out extensively to forge Bateman's chiseled physique. Co-star Willem Dafoe praised his performance, remembering, "I think he's excellent in the movie. It's one of his best roles. He was like a machine." Roger Ebert lays most of the film's success on Bale's shoulders, writing in his initial review that the actor "is heroic in the way he allows the character to leap joyfully into despicability; there is no instinct for self-preservation here, and that is one mark of a good actor." Bale has since been honored with four Academy Award nominations and one win, though many consider his role as the music-loving murderer to be a career-high... so far. 

Karyn Kusama is an artist with a lamentable track record of being unappreciated. After sharing the Grand Jury Prize and winning an award for dramatic directing at the 2000 Sundance Film Festival for her debut, "Girlfight," Kusama helmed the critically panned "Æon Flux," which landed her in what she describes as "director's jail," and the criminally maligned "Jennifer's Body," a picture currently in the midst of a massive cultural reevaluation.

More grounded in reality, Kusama's fourth effort, "The Invitation," follows a grieving father who attends a dinner party thrown by his ex-wife and her new lover. The evening slowly devolves into shocking acts of violence as Kusama explores grief, paranoia, and the reality of death. Many fans mention John Carroll Lynch's unnerving performance and a taut script by Phil Hay and Matt Manfredi, but the lion's share of praise has been reserved for Kusama, with Heather Wixson calling it, "some of the most assuredly confident and nuanced work from [Kusama] to date and one of the most devastating horror films I've seen in years." Despite this praise, the versatile director has so far been completely neglected by the Academy, which is perhaps not surprising given its notorious lack of nominations for female filmmakers.

The Academy loves to reward films that push the envelope and make important social statements, often giving bonus points to stories that rip our hearts out along the way. The Australian production "Lake Mungo" perfectly fits this description and remains one of the most unique and emotionally complex horror flicks of the past few decades. Written and directed by Joel Anderson, this faux documentary focuses on a family still reeling from the drowning death of their teenage daughter Alice (Talia Zucker). When she seems to appear in photos taken by her brother, Alice's family starts to unravel the mystery of her tragic demise.

Anderson uses the expository format to lay out the facts of this twisting story while highlighting the emotional impact of each event. Operating from an unscripted outline, Anderson guided his performers through their talking-head interviews with an uncredited role as the faceless interviewer. Few who have seen "Lake Mungo” can forget its devastating exploration of grief and depression, wrung out in a series of shocking reveals. Unfortunately, the film came and went with virtually no fanfare and was likely missed by many Academy voters. Recent campaigns to garner Oscar nominations have generated controversy, but "Lake Mungo" is a prime example of an award-worthy film overlooked without the backing of a major studio.