TIFF Review: What Doesn't Kill You

Ten years ago, the Boston film scene was almost non existent. Most films that were set in the bay state were actually filmed on soundstages in Canada and Los Angeles. Good Will Hunting was probably the biggest modern film to have shot in the area, and even then, the lack of tax incentives pushed the majority of the production out of state. The occasional indie film like Next Stop Wonderland dared to do what Hollywood couldn't, that is until Clint Eastwood and Martin Scorsese came to town. It's funny how much things have changed in the last decade. As South Boston has taken the center stage, the Boston-story seems to have become a subgenre of the gangster film.

Brian Goodman's What Doesn't Kill You is the latest entry of the Southie tales. Based on a true story of two childhood friends who turn to crime to get by. The film opens in a flash forward, with a trio of gangsters pulling a armored car robbery outside a small strip mall. But things go wrong when a Cop shows up. Paulie (Ethan Hawke) rips off his ski mask and walks towards the police man with his gun blaring. Freeze frame.

"One thing that always stuck with me on the street; Never do armored trucks."

We then cut to many years earlier, and are told the non-glitsy story of how the brothers became involved in organized crime, which involves picking up an envelope and stealing boxes of cigarettes from the back of a delivery truck. The editing in the beginning of the movie is really incoherent, and I hate to say it, could probably have been better told through a montage. Fifteen years later Brian (Mark Ruffalo) is in a dysfunctional marriage with Amanda Peet, staying out until the later morning hours. Brian has become both an alcoholic and a druggie, trying to score some quick cash before the last batch runs out and the duo have been reduced to kidnapping a poodle for a $5000 pay day.

What Doesn't Kill You begins like a really bad version of Goodfellas. I had pretty much given up on the film in the first 25 minutes because of it's low-fi approach. Boy was I wrong. The problem is that the film isn't a South Boston Gangster film, but instead a family drama that takes place in this Southie gangster setting. This becomes more apparent when Brian and Paulie are arrested and sentenced to five years in prison. What Doesn't Kill You is about Brian's return to the real world, and his struggle to stay clean for his wife and two children. You want Brian to find a legit job, but this is harder than it sounds when all you know is the quick score and all your friends are degenerates. And with the opening reveal of the armored car robbery, we know where the story must eventually head. The armored car robbery is the ticking time bomb underneath the table that Hitchcock always talked about.

Donnie Wahlberg has a small supporting performance as a police detective who is waiting and watching for Brian to screw up. Wahlberg, a Boston native, also co-wrote the screenplay with Goodman. Mark Ruffalo's performance walks a narrow line, making you root for the screw up loser who has already been given too many chances. The character's redeeming qualities could fit into a small box, but Ruffalo is able to earn your empathy, even in a situation which seems hopeless. Amanda Peet distracts from the steady flow with over dramatic outbursts. The piano and violin score is haunting and reminiscent of The Nines. I later realized that composer Alex Wurman also provided the music for John August's directorial debut.

/Film Rating: 7.5 out of 10