noomi_rapace

Another international phenomenon is about to get a US remake, probably before you’ve even had a chance to catch the original. Doesn’t mean the Stateside do-over isn’t sounding tasty, though…

The biggest crowd pleaser at this year’s Frightfest was the English speaking world’s premiere of a smart, pointed thriller in the Silence of the Lambs vein, though with added politics. The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is an adaptation of the first book in Stieg Larsson’s worldwide smash novel trilogy Millennium, known as Män som hatar kvinnor in its native Sweden - a title that would translate literally as Men Who Hate Women. It’s a rather apt title.

The deal for US adaptations of the book series is closing now, with Sony reported to be tying up the last loose ends of some rather complex negotiations. Things have apparently been slower than with normal rights negotiations, largely due to the sudden death of Larsson shortly before the publication of the first novel, and the ensuing entanglements when it became clear that he had neither married his common law wife or left a will; and partly due to the existence of the Swedish film versions.

Linked to the project are screenwriter Steve Zaillian and producer Scott Rudin. That’s a real power player duo and they give the project a genuine whiff of Oscar even before a single word has been scripted.

Back when we first commented on a possible US remake, Russ passed on news that Brad Pitt and Quentin Tarantino were supposedly interested in snapping up the rights. Anne Thompson now tells us that Tarantino’s agent has issued a denial, which is a great shame. She doesn’t mention Pitt, but does say that George Clooney has been rumoured as an interested party along the way. He’d make great casting for Mikael Blomkvist (Michael Bloom in the US?), the male lead of the series.

The female lead, Lisbeth Salender, is the series’ most powerful weapon and would be a highly prized role for any actresses in range. In the Swedish films she’s played by Noomi Rapace, pictured at the head of the post, in a true starmaker of a turn. Don’t be surprised if she crosses over to have an American career - heck, she could even end up reprising the role she originated in the Swedish films for these remakes. Anne Thompson suggests Ellen Page, Kristen Stewart or Natalie Portman but I can only really see Page nailing it as already written. Who knows what Zaillian will turn Lisbeth into, though?

Here’s a mini-review from my Frightfest roundup showing just what Rudin and Zaillian would have to live up to, or for that matter straighten out:

This 2 and a half hour adaptation of Steig Larson’s internationally best selling novel played like a good TV mystery drama in the European vein – a Rebus, Wallander or Spiral as opposed to CSI or Without a Trace, say. It wasn’t at all bad, despite being intermittently dull and oftentimes predictable. The best scenes were great though, and there’s one particularly cinematic clue with a series of sequenced photographs that reminded me of something similar in American Gangster. When the film doesn’t work it’s because the adaptation is too faithful to the novel, sticking to the workings of a medium in which long strings of dialogue and verbal exposition are as welcome and functionally suitable as chunks of action.

Note my reference to American Gangster, a previous adaptation with a Steve Zaillian script. Eat that, Nostradamus.

The Swedish version of The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo hits US cinemas in March. Expect to see it on a lot of Year’s Best lists this time next year.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

  • Jordankosmac
    Leave these movies alone..they were fine in Swedish
  • leo spohr
    Millenium's Fake, the U.S. version.
  • Klixton
    I do not understand why the cinema industry of U. S. remake some movies Scandinavians. Is it because of Puritanism, to cut scenes of nudity and kisses between women? My advice is: make no mistake with explosions and bed sheets covering bodies: see the original!
  • Saw this movie last night in Bristol UK. It is very long but well-paced and it is engaging. Excellent plot-lines and story that keeps you guessing. Interesting characters. Good direction. Highly enjoyable movie that is occassionally a bit gruesome. I give it 4 stars.
  • I don't think so!
    I think it will be hard to find an actor to play Lisbeth Salander! If you've seen the second film you should know what I'm talking about! Can you really imagine Kristen Stewart or "Juno" doing the extreme lesbian sex scenes? I don't think so! And I don't think the american version can become as scary as the swedish, cause as someone talked about earlier, the "bad" editing. It's it's natural feeling that makes it so crazy scary! Too many effects and too good-looking actors makes it so unrealistic!
  • A-K87
    Does everyone realise that Sony aren't remaking the Swedish film?? They are adapting a more international interpretation from the same book. It's all about interpretation. I think the Americans will do well to take a different angle in casting so to distingiush the two movies. Noomi Rapace was ace but maybe Sony will cast someone who is actualy below 5ft and weedy and has an 'almost asian look'. I think that they'll set it in USA and Canada (after all Hedeby Island and Hedestad are made up places anyway.)

    I love this trilogy and I'm excited about yet another potentially good interpretation of the novels. Sony are rolling out the same production team which did the Swedish films to work with Scott Rudin and Steve Zaillian to adapt the script; I'm thinking that they're treating this seriously. I prey that they don't dumb it down for the (no offence) Middle Americans.
  • Gob Bluth
    I think George Clooney is perfect. Brad Pitt is too handsome and not at all how I pictured Kalle Blomkvist. Maybe Matthew Macfadyen or Clive Owen. I can't see Ellen Page being as mysterious and intensely violent as Lisbeth is in the books. I hate Twilight so I really would rather not see Kristen Stewart in it. I could see the girl who plays the daughter in The United States of Tara if she was older or Angelina Jolie if she was younger... I know nobody will agree with me but I could see Anna Paquin/Gwenyth Paltrow/Keira Knightley. Mostly though I just hope they do the book justice.
  • Elle
    I picture Krysten Ritter when I read the books.
    she's been in a couple of movies but not really well known.
    she looks the part. I'm tired of George Clooney being the lead in everything.
    there are plenty of good actors they should consider and give him a rest.

  • Daniël
    Is this al you Americans can do, clone films made by others?
    Why don't you try and wait till the film come's to you.
  • Jennifer
    Hi Brendon,

    Long-time reader, first time commenter on this one. :) (I just feel strongly about these books.)

    I actually have to disagree with your casting ideas up above. Clooney does seem like an obvious choice (the older, handsome, lady-killer who can be charming like in "Up in the Air" and edgy like in "Syriana"), but he doesn't seem to fit. And I laughed at all three of your suggestions for Salander (no offense intended). I kind of described it in a post above as a reply to another commenter, but I truly think that the actress playing Salander needs to come out of the shadows in the same way that the character of Salander does. No one in that movie audience should have any preconceived notions about the actress playing Salander. I feel like you just picked brunette actresses who were petite and could be capable of an edgier role.

    Just like actress Gabby Sidibe came into the Hollywood scene to play the lead role in "Precious," some unknown actress out there right now will come on the scene to define Salander for American audiences. And hopefully Scott Rudin doesn't ruin it by picking someone already defined.
  • I completely agree with your take on who, if anyone at all, should play an American Lisbeth Salander. And now I'll be contrary and say that if there were to be an American adaptation, I'd like to see Liam Neeson take on Blomkvist.
  • A-K87
    Liam Neeson is too old. Late 50s. He's got the looks but they're blatantly going to go for someone more handsome than Mikael is described. I think Dominic West from the Wire could do it well. They're gonna go for Clooney for the box office pulling power. Are we agreed that Kristen Stewart would be a disaster??
  • Heidi
    OK. I can see what you are saying. And to address the Kristen Stewart thing - no way. She would not be good.
  • A-K87
    Ellen Page in Hard Candy is basically Salander
  • Heidi
    Oh yeah, Mila could even pass for having Russian heritage.
    Yeah, Berger is blonde I think, but Eva could pull of a lighter shade. Ellen Page could be great, but I am not sure if he has enough dept as an actress to play someone so hardcore. The her looks (looking child-like) are perfect.
  • A-K87
    Shannyn Sossamon has the looks. I think someone not too hot though. The height is really restricting with actresses. Ever since I read it I've thought about Ellen Page. Mila Kunis perhaps? I think they're go for a big name like Julia Roberts for Berger. She can pull off the professional, wise yet sex driven executive type. Eva Green is one of my fave actresses though but isn't Beger blonde?
  • Heidi
    Salander is really a tough one. My first thought is a no-name. But if I had to pick someone I'd say maybe Rachel Bilson if she could be edgy and not so cutesy, or Shannyn Sossamon, but she seems like she might be too tall. I guess I don't have a great suggestion for her. I would like Eva Green for Erika Berger.
  • A-K87
    I can see what you're saying Heidi but Jon Hamm is just a bit too polished for Kalle Blomkvist. It might be just because I'm so used to seeing him in Mad Men. I reckon someone who isn't such a known face of Hollywood would be great though. Who do you think should do Salander?
  • Heidi
    I'm telling you all Jon Hamm is the best Mikael. He's handsome enough that you can see why all the chicks want to sleep with him. But he also has the dopey vulnerable thing going, so you can see why Salander would trust him.
  • Heidi
    I think Jon Hamm from Mad Men would be the perfect kalle blomkvist. As for Lisbeth, I agree - she should be a newcomer.
  • Wolfwhistle
    Ugh.. Noomi rapace isn't that great in these movies. Like every other Swedish actor/actress she is kinda overplaying. But, eventhough this movie suffered from overplaying actors, poor editing like almost every big swedish movie, it was kinda enjoyable. But I have no doubt that the remake will be better. Let the right one in, the original is brilliant though, don't think the American version will be better
  • I whole-heartedly disagree with you, but I unfortunately don't know enough about Swedish film to comment on your assessment of the acting. I really enjoyed this movie just as it is and I think that removing the things that make the movie Swedish would just ruin it.
  • Kashve
    I agree totally. Please don't do a remake of this film (or these 3 films) but rather a new adaption of the books. There are easily a great amount of storytelling in them to make a US version superb!
  • I've heard many reports that the movie just felt too fast but I will wait to see the original if I'm ever given the chance.
  • Philippe
    The original movie was ok until the end where they rushed in a bunch of stuff to prepare for the sequel.
  • Question, is the Lisbeth girl supposed to be full on Swedish?
  • Stefan
    Actually, there's a twist to that as well. You'll have to read or watch parts 2 and 3 to get a full answer to that.

    However, the answer has no bearing on your question presumably being based on the notion that all "real" Swedes are blond and blue-eyed? That, though, is not necessarily the case, we come in all sorts of colours these days :-)
  • BrendonConnelly
    All of the (main) characters are, I believe. Why do you ask?
  • Gus
    Ellen Page would be awesome. She could channel the same type of energy as in 'Hard Candy'.
  • Jennifer
    No, no, no, no way. The majority of fans would look at Ellen Page and see "Juno."

    I swear, if Hollywood messes up the casting of Lisbeth, it would ruin the movie. They need a new face. Someone who no audience member would feasibly recognize, in the same way that readers come to the books not having any idea of Salander's past.

    The suggestions above are too entrenched in Hollywood already. Ellen Page would equal "Juno", Natalie Portman would be "the girl from Garden State/Star Wars", and Kristen Stewart would just piss people off. I'm sorry, but you can't go from being Bella Swan to being Lisbeth-effing awesome-Salander. You just can't.
  • A-K87
    Ellen Page fits the description of Salander perfectly. Don't get me wrong, Noomi Rapace was excellent, but she didn't fit the physical description perfectly. Salander is 4'9ish, 24, flat chested and so skinny she could easily be mistaken for a 15 yr old boy. She's described as having high cheek bones and an 'almost asian' look. Hard Candy and Ellen Page's intensity in that role is the perfect audition. Everyone watched that film and you'll agree with me and Gus. I would love an unknown, but that's not going to happen in Hollywood! p.s. Dominic West (The Wire) for Blomqvist! (Although George Clooney is inevitable.)
  • I saw that movie not too long ago. god, it was CRAZY. so good.
  • Name
    Not to be picky, but: It should read Lisbeth Salander, not "Lisbeth Salender".
  • BrendonConnelly
    What's an a between friends?
  • Frederik
    Män som hatar kvinnor was a really good movie. Sucks they thought it wouldn't be successfull so they decided to go cut alot from the budget in the two sequels and get rid of the first director who practically made the movie so good.

    Also funny how USA is changing the title. Always so politically correct :).
  • Jennifer
    I don't think the title change had anything to do with being politically correct. I this the US publishers of the books wanted a better hook for the trilogy, and you can't deny the THE GIRL series is seeing a lot of success. I think the US titles are more effective in singling out why the story is so unique (read: Salander), instead of having a generalization as a title (though MEN WHO HATE WOMEN) is still provocative.
blog comments powered by Disqus