lookingglasswars

Frank Beddor has been in the news this week. First there was that awful, awful premise for Ridley Scott’s movie version of Monopoly that Beddor wrote and explained to the LA Times. Now he’s taken to television to promote his latest book, and while there mentioned that Chuck Roven, one of the producers on The Dark Knight, is working on an adaptation of Beddor’s novel series The Looking Glass Wars. I haven’t read the books, perhaps they’re wonderful, but the revamped approach to Alice in Wonderland sounds just as terrible as the Monopoly pitch.

When asked about a film version of The Looking Glass Wars, what Beddor specifically said today on Good Morning America, as related by ComingSoon, was:

I am working with the producer of ‘The Dark Knight’ Chuck Roven, so we’re putting it together, and it’s pretty exciting to think about it as a movie. It’s a really visual world so we’ll see.

What is this visual world? Here’s the Booklist rundown, via Amazon:

Alyss Heart, heir to the Wonderland throne, is forced to flee when her vicious aunt Redd murders her parents, the King and Queen of Hearts. She escapes through the Pool of Tears to Victorian London, but she finds she has no way home. Adopted by the Liddells, who christen her Alice Liddell and disapprove of her wild stories about Wonderland, Alyss begs Charles Dodgson to tell her real story. Even though he writes Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, she knows no one believes her. Years go by, with Alice repressing her memories. Then royal bodyguard Hatter Madigan, determined to start a war for Wonderland’s throne, crashes her wedding. Beddor offers some intriguing reimaginings of Dodgson’s concepts (such as looking-glass travel) and characters (the cat is an assassin with nine lives), but his transformation of Wonderland’s lunacy into a workable world sometimes leads to stilted exposition on history, geography, and government.

First there was the video game American McGee’s Alice (and the potential movie adaptation of same) and now this? Luckily Carroll’s material is strong enough to stand on its own. So, if this is actually a wonderful development, tell us why in the comments below. Something more than ‘the books are awesome!’ would be helpful.

  • Watcinema
    This premise sounds very silly. I, however, would honestly like to see American McGee's Alice see production. I'd like to see Alice's story in a more nightmarish fashion, much more than what Tim Burton is going for. The premise of a girl in a psychiatric ward literally battling her inner demons via an imagined wonderland sounds cool to me.

    Also, Hatter Madigan? LOL
  • RussFischer
    A lot of people like American McGee's Alice for that reason -- nightmarish Alice -- though I thought it was fairly obvious and overwrought, kinda the opposite of nightmarish.

    For a truly creepy version of Alice I always look to Jan Svankmajer's 1988 stop-motion version. It's got the irritating cutaways to Alice and her constant "...said the White Rabbit" voiceover, yes. But the character designs are amazing. Really truly inspired and freakish stuff in there.
  • righteousplaid
    Jan Svankmajer's Alice is pretty much the definitive "creepy Alice" movie out there.
  • Jaby
    Ive read the books and they are amazing! Very different from Alice in Wonderland but very similar in ways aswell. With Burton's Alice in Wonderland coming so soon I doubt an audience will want to see another adaptation.
  • fanboy
    I enjoyed the first Looking Glass Wars book (and the comic spin-off, Hatter M), but with both a sequel to American McGee's Alice and Tim Burton's movie coming out pretty soon, this may not be the right time to start developing it.
  • El
    I read the books, and the premise itself was entertaining (I like what he did with Hatter and "Alyss"), but I found the writing itself to be...amateurish? I don't know, in the right hands it could turn out to be an excellent movie or two, and since I'm an Alice in Wonderland fan I'd be interested. The potentials there, but there would have to be a lot of thought behind it.
  • Antihero
    I gotta agree with you on this one, We met Frank Beddor at emerald city comicon (Seattle) last year and he was a really nice guy, very personable. Too bad his book was a horrible let down.
  • dottieditto
    I read the looking glass wars when it first came out, and it has a really interesting premise and sets up a very interesting world with some good action, but the story is meh at best. with the right script, it could be good. even without one it'll probably be fun to watch, so i'm looking forward to it either way
  • I've been waiting for this announcement since I read the first book a few years ago. I believe the story will translate to film very well, as long as it's handled correctly. Hatter Madigan is a bad a** as is the Cat.I was hoping T. Burton would do these, but probably not as he is already doing the original Alice in Wonderland.
  • PugsMasterFlex
    Didn't they alread make this? I beleive it was called Hook?
  • The first few pages of the Looking Glass Wars was loosely based on Alice in Wonderland. After that, it was just a run of the mill fantasy novel about a girl named Alyss.
  • Anthony
    You really should read the books. It took no more than a chapter for me to get hooked and blaze through the first two. I think counted the days for the third book to hit shelves. The story is just that good. I'd rather see these adapted into a movie than let Burton ruin Alice for me.
blog comments powered by Disqus