Lawsuit Could Stop Spielberg’s Oldboy Remake

When it was first announced that Steven Spielberg and Will Smith were developing an American remake of Chan-wook Park’s Oldboy with the screenwriter of Poseidon, fans freaked out. It was later revealed that the remake wasn’t a remake at all, but an American adaptation of the original Japanese manga by Nobuaki Minegishi and Garon Tsuchiya, which Park’s film was based on. Even though the book and the movie deviate from one another, fans were still not pleased.

Well now fans can rest happy (at least for a bit) as AnimeNewsNetwork is reporting that Japanese publisher Futabasga is suing the Korean film production company Show East over the rights to remake the story in Hollywood.

According to the report in ANN:

Futabasha is suing to confirm the lack of a binding contract between the two parties, due to an alleged breach. Futabasha asserts that Show East violated its basic agreement with Futabasha, and thus nullified it, when Show East pushed for the production of a film remake with America’s Universal Pictures. Show East signed its contract with Futabasha over film rights in September of 2002, and signed a second contract in December of 2003 that amended the original one to cover other materials.

In the 2003 South Korean film, a man named Dae-Su is locked in a hotel room for 15 years without knowing why or who is holding him captive. He is suddenly released, given money, clothes and a cellphone and is sent on journey for revenge. The film won the Grand Prix at the 2004 Cannes Film Festival and was highly praised by Jury President Quentin Tarantino. Praised for it’s intense visuals and twisted story, Oldboy was met with positive reviews in the States, and is currently getting an 82% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and an 8.3 user rating on IMDB, for a #117 placement on the top 250 films of all time.

Read the official book synopsis below:

“Ten years ago, they took him. He doesn’t know who. For ten years he has been confined in a private prison. He doesn’t know why. For ten years his only contact with the outside world has been a television set and the voices of his jailers. In time, he lost himself. He changed . . . transformed himself into something else . . . something hard . . . something lethal. Suddenly one day, his incarceration ends, again without explanation. He is sedated, stuffed inside a trunk, and dumped in a park. When he awakes, he is free to reclaim what’s left of his life . . . and what’s left is revenge.”

The Onion AV Club says that “the manga’s story isn’t nearly as propulsive and grim as the film version, but as soon as their plotlines begin to deviate, the manga becomes just as compelling.” So while the short plot synopsis sounds similar, it appears that the film adaptation did deviate from Minegishi and Tsuchiya’s original manga. For those that might be interested, Amazon has each of the three volumes available for around 10 or 11 bucks each.

via: cinemablend

  • twiztidfreak
    Loved the original and I sure hope that the remake never happens. and if it does PLEASE do not use will smith and stephen spielberg This is definetly not mo vie for their style. it will just be an abomanation.
  • sweet juicy justice
  • Since what the world really needs is a PG-13 story of revenge, which is what it would be. I'm sure that I'll be the opposite of compelling. Hope the remake never sees the light of day.
  • Can't they do this to every remake?

    Ok, I know why they can't since this is sorta an exception but I'd love this to happen a lot more
  • Good to hear :)
  • YAY! Now I can watch OLDBOY again without worry. Well, there is still worry until this suit is final, but I hope this scares off Spielberg and Will Smith.
  • I'll help pay for the lawyer fees if it helps keep this remaking/whatever from happening
  • I dont think a remake is necessary, the orginial was great.
  • God I hope this stops what I'm sure would be a catastrophe. Although I doubt that it will. If it does get made, it'll probably be worse than Zinda.
  • nelson
    AW Hell Naw
  • sitrom
    People just watch Oldboy. It's all we need.

    I need another Oldboy film as much as I need another Indy film.
  • b d
    thank god. seriously.
  • YAY! Now I can watch OLDBOY again without worry. Well, there is still worry until this suit is final, but I hope this scares off Spielberg and Will Smith.
  • sitrom
    People just watch Oldboy. It's all we need.

    I need another Oldboy film as much as I need another Indy film.
  • not getting the indy film part.
  • ...
    I think this is good and bad news...
    While I'm kind of sad I won't see Will Smith in what could be a really edgy role for him, I also don't think Oldboy needs to be remade.
    Though critically acclaimed, I wasn't a huge fan of Oldboy...
    the ending really through me off.
    ...
  • itsallgood013
    You know, I don't get all the hubbub about Spielberg and Smith being not good for this movie... Being a fan of Oldboy, here are my thoughts...

    Even if they make this movie into some sort of terrible monstrosity, the original still isn't going anywhere... Meaning: If the new one sucks, just watch the old one again and be happy.

    I would be excited to see what the Spielberg/Smith combo could do with this.
  • Lawdog
    Could we please just get some Asian movies in wide release in the US already? Do we have to keep getting the crappy Americanized version? Bangcock Dangerous is another one that would have been even more frigging awesome in a theater. But Nooooooo, we have to get Nic Cage playing the mute assassin. Wait! Nic Cage can't be mute! He's making $20 million! You don't pay someone $20 mill to run around without saying a word!
    *cough*Tom Hanks*cough*Oscarnom
    I have a pretty big big-screen tv, but some of these movies need to be seen on THE big screen first.

    I wonder when we'll be hearing about the new Zac Efron Ang-Bak movie...
  • Lawdog
    Ong-Bak*
  • I am siding with you Mondo Jay. I didn't need this remake in the first place, the OG film is so strong, but I was looking forward to seeing if Willie could pull this off. In Spielberg I DO NOT trust though. We'll see what happens.
    The Rake
    http://thefilmnest.com
  • oldboys
    In the manga, Dae-su Oh was a much more sympathetic character who was driven to find reason instead of vengeance. Park Chan-Wook's film is inimitable; if Spielberg stays close to the original source material, he can have an original film as well. Will Smith has proved he can portray a lonely, tortured soul with his role in I Am Legend. A good movie could be made here and it's a shame if it gets shut down so coldly.
  • There are *eight* volumes in the manga. I'm pretty sure y'all made that mistake last time you posted about Old Boy too. :\
  • joe
    man i love oldboy but i had no idea it was a manga adaptation
    as long as they dont try to remake it over here...
  • OldboyfanAtiK
    THANK YOU LORD FOR ANSWERING MY PRAYERS !!!
    THANK YOU GOD!!!!
    This is one of the best news i've heard this year \:d/ !
  • Rockie
    hurm
  • Oliver
    this is great news, no more nightmares of will smith rapping while he clobbers people in a hallway with a hammer.
  • rumplstiltskin
    What on earth are you guys thinking?!
    What's wrong with the movie the way it is?

    But if you just HAVE to do it.......I'd say use Gary Oldman for Oh Daesu's part....not Will Smith.
blog comments powered by Disqus