Rumor Killer: Ghostbuster 3 Casting

Don’t believe those Ghostbuster rumors… A new live-action Ghostbusters film is not in the works. A rumor has been circulating the interwebs that Dan Akroyd, Bill Murray, Harold Ramis and Ernie Hudson had signed on to return for a third film where they would hand off the Ghostbusting duties to the Judd Apatow crew of Seth Rogen, Steve Carell, Paul Rudd, and Romany Malco. I’ll admit, that it doesnt sound like a bad idea, at least in best case scenario terms, but it’s completely untrue.

The Ghostbuster 3 rumors began at WonderCon 2008, where an advertisement in the program promised a big Ghostbusters related announcement in San Diego. The announcement never happened, but was expected to be the Ghostbusters video game. But even that is on hiatus now as part of the recently announced Activision cuts. The planned announcement, combined with a Ghostbusters fan contest fueled the current rumor.

Discuss: But now that we’re here, who would you recast in a new Ghostbusters movie?

  • gah
    That would be a good idea. I would love to see a Ghostbusters with those guys.
  • Oh Blair
    I always make that joke when someone says who you gonna call?

    GHOSTBUSTERS! LOL
  • GregoryV
    Judd Apatow and the geek squad would be such a great team for Ghostbuster 3.
  • Rex
    If the game is a success then there might be more interest in a movie but I doubt anything will happen before that.

    The game is sort of in limbo, Activision cut them loose to find a new publisher instead of using Sierra though there is some confusion that Sierra may still exist and the game will be published under that label.
  • Christopher Edwards
    Judd Apatow has to much pull with different movies now, even to have rumour like this to his name is somthing that could of happend.


    But let sleeping dogs lie and these dogs are sleeping.
  • Tom
    I think a Ghostbusters "reboot" with the 40 Year Old Virgin team would be excellent. The original Ghostbusters SNL cast were pretty much in the same place as the Apatow gang before Ghosbusters (ie silly, gross-out-style comedies), so it'd make sense.

    Well, except that it was only a rumour....
  • Ben
    I wouldn't have thought it would have worked before, but seeing that picture above makes me hope they do see some sense and put it into production. Has the potential to be brilliant!
  • Whiskey
    Can't be worse than Ghostbusters 2, right?
    "VIGO!"
  • thomas
    judd apatow and his gang would do great with ghostbusters cause there is no doubt in my mind that they have massive respect for the movie. i dont like that black guy tho, he isnt very subtle...
  • Al
    Should have a female ghostbuster imo
  • I liked GB2 but I also agree that you shall never wake up sleeping dogs. Okay, Apatow could handle it. But the humour has to be dark, I think :)
  • Derek
    Vince Vaughn - Peter Venkman
    Rainn Wilson - Egon Spengler
    Don Cheadle - Winston Zeddemore
    Owen Wilson - Ray Stantz

    Do it
  • Captain Awesome
    No one because all those goons put together couldn't do what Bill Murray did.
  • J'osh
    I always liked the idea of a Simon Pegg/Edgar Wright written and produced Ghostbusters 3.
  • REAL6
    the 40 Year Old Virgin team arent even on the same caliber as the SNL crew!!!

    Now J'osh, i rather see Pegg, Wright and frost for G3.

    Seth and gang are not funny to me. Just some fat kids in every movie!!!
  • Burt Waldo
    If was ever to be done, it's not a bad choice, provided they don't do their awful, lame improv bits that they always do in their movies - for which Paul Rudd is particularly annoying.
    No one can match Bill Murray though.
  • Patrick
    This is a pretty old rumor. It started when an untitled Harold Ramis and Eisner project on www.imdb.com . Originally it was rumored that Ben Stiller, Vince Vaughn, and their crew were to takeover the reins.

    Then the rumor went to a video game only of Ghostbusters 3. Now it is at another live action rumor.
  • A Better Class of Criminal
    I love this idea... if only it were true.

    Seth Rogen=Peter Venkman
    Paul Rudd=Ray Stantz
    Steve Carrell=Egon Spengler
    Romany Malco=Winston Zeddemore

    I do have to agree with Captian Awesome though... Bill Murray can't be outdone.

    Perhaps if this ever happened he could have a substancial cameo.
  • Quenfis
    I would definitely see this movie with those guys. I think it would be hysterical. Murray made both of those films worth watching. But, the Apatow gang could bring some serious funny to the table.
  • Jenbot
    cool, smart ass guys. Not guys that we can laugh at and feel sorry for, no we need totall smart ass guys that are cool as shit like Bill Murray. We need talented comedians that can also play cool guys.

    Paul Rudd=Peter Venkman (come one now, Venkman was the suave cool guy)
    thats all I got for now
  • Steve
    I wonder why Apatow has not used Malco in ANYTHING since virgin.
  • I like Derek's idea, but I would switch it up just a bit:

    Vince Vaughn - Peter Venkman
    Rainn Wilson - Egon Spengler
    Don Cheadle - Winston Zeddemore
    Seth Rogen - Ray Stantz

    Wasn't sure about Cheadle at first, but now that I think about it, he was great in a similar role in the Ocean's series.
  • jimbo stewart
    I'd cast Vincent Gallo as Peter Venkman
    John C. Reilly as Ray Stantz
    Fred Williamson as Winston Zeddemore
    Jeffrey Combs as Egon Spengler
  • Steelo
    I wouldn't recast. Let's try an original idea for once. It JUST might work.
  • this is great why cant it be real
  • D.A.
    yea it wouldnt be a recast, it says right there that the
    original guys would come back to hand off the reins to a new set of ghostbusters
  • JB
    This is a great idea... 40YOV is one of the most rewatchable movies ever. I think the cast could take GB up a notch. We need to start a petition to get this thing going...
  • Jerris Beutler's Day On
    Why are they wearing cartoon uniforms in that pic?
  • Jerris Beutler's Day On
    Is the rumor that this is going to be some kind of Who Framed Roger Rabbit live action/animated hybrid? :0
  • Joey
    can McLovin(Mintz-Plasse) reprise Rick Moranis' role? hahahahahahhaha
  • McLovin
    Should they do this movie, Ray, Egon, and Winston are distraught after Peter dies, becomes a ghost bent on taking over NYC- Dan Akroyd being so overweight and the whole team being old hire a new team-
    John Cho from Harold and Kumar
    Jonah Hill from Superbad and Accepted
    Neil Patrick Harris
    Steve Carrell
    And Mclovin from should come in and be their secretary!
  • Tom
    I'm so glad you guys that came up with your own alternate castings don't work in Hollywood.

    Don Cheadle? Really? Especially based on his Oceans performances. Geez.

    Worst. Accent. EVER.
  • Father Bradley
    David Burnce = Ray
    Michael Hutchinson = Winston
    Rob Bonstin = Venkman
    Larry Hoki = Egon
  • Wait a Sec!...who's playing Jake Kong & Eddie Spencer? Will this one include Tracy the beanie wearing gorilla? Bonus points if you know what I'm talking about.

    Ghostbusters III should tell the tale of a the UK franchise where everything in use is held together by duck tape and bailing wire. They don't really have the ability to contain ghosts, its more of a catch and relocate program.

    UK Ghostbusters:
    Simon Pegg
    Nick Frost
    David Tennant
    Rupert Gint - Dana's son Oscar.

    American:
    Steve Carrell - Ghostbusters, Inc. CFO
  • fex
    Im with jimbo. If your going to take the piss then might as well take a long one.
  • Derek
    Tom, opinions are like elbows.

    As far as Don Cheadle goes, he is in fact an exceptional actor. Performances in Hotel Rwanda, Crash, and Reign Over Me assure me of this. One oscar nomination for Hotel Rwanda... but what does the Academy know, it's not like *they're* people that work in Hollywood.
  • deez
    My girlfriend and I actually just had sex last night while watching ghostbusters II. That aside, I have an idea. STOP with the fucking remakes. There is not a cast on earth who could pull of ghostbusters like the original. This is one of those movies you leave the fuck alone. I'll tell you, this pisses me off almost as bad as when I read about the Bill & Ted remake a little earlier. FUCK THAT. and no, this is not about "ruining my childhood" or any of that bullshit, this is about coming up with original ideas and making good fucking movies again. Christ, for as long as everybody has been making fun of the eighties, we sure love to come back to it. FUCK howard stern for remaking rock and roll high school, FUCK darren arofnofnfossky (who I admired up until now, spelling intentional) for remaking robocop, and FUCK rogen and appatow for thinking because they made some stupid fucking stoner movie that has been done 1,000 times before that they feel the need to remake more dumbass stoner comedies and remakes of movies that are 1,000 times funnier than anything they could make on their own. NO originality left. /rant, and feel free to point out grammatical and spelling errors at your leisure, because I just typed for the sake of typing and if spelling errors are the best you can come up with, fuck you, too. :)
  • Someone make this movie now.
  • Tom
    Derek - I get that Don Cheadle's a good - well, great - actor. I just didn't agree with the opinion that his role in the Ocean's movies made him suitable for Ghostbusters.

    But then, Ghostbusters isn't Hotel Rwanda, either. I dunno, maybe he has some Robert Downey Jr-esque comic talents hidden away.
  • dopiestghost
    I also must point out that Bill Murray's performance in this movie simply cannot be outdone. In fact, his performance is so seminal that it's the reason I cannot rank TDK about Ghostbusters in my favorite movie list (they sit tied at #2).
  • Derek
    Tom, fair enough, good points.
  • Please, Please let this just be a rumor. I like the Judd Apatow crew but i would hate them for this. I have faith in their ability to make good movies but i don't even think the original crew can put this together. And pass it off to Steve Carell, Seth Rogan and the rest of that crew is outrageous, cast the fucking parts to actors that will fit, this will be a bad slapstick comedy that is full of the same lame jokes. There is definitely a better group of comedic actors that fit the roles. Sorry Steve Carell does not belong in this movie, he can be funny in the right movie but this isn't it. I'm looking forward to pineapple express, an original movie, stop butchering classic 80's movies because you can't think of anything new, and if it's some scumbag producer with a lack of originality, please somebody put this douche down.
  • dvd
    well, if dan and harold write some very fun stuff for these guys...why not?
  • Patrick
    The Ghostbusters 3 movie will be made in CGI because Bill Murray agreed to voice his role and it will be the 4 orignal GB's in GB3 providing there voices in GB3. The movie will be here in 2009 so it's coming in 2009 hang on tight! I'm glad that the GB3 movie will have the orignal actors providing there voices in CGI for the third film!
  • sONY pICTURES
    hi, i'm the real Sony....you know...i've made Spiderman and some others fantastic movies!
    Ghostbusters 3 will be here....but in 2010 and live action because Bill Murray has agreed to do a little role....
    WE'll have Dan Aykroyd as Doctor Stantz'd father, Ray Stantz and Ray Stantz nephew.
    we'll have Harold Ramis (he has put himself on a diet to lose weight) as Egon Spengler and Slimer's brother. (and he'll voice Slimer babies!!)
    we'll have Bill Murray as a retired Peter Venkman.
    we'll have Ernie Hudson as Winston's cousin because winston will die at the very beginnig of the movie.
    we'll have an ecto-helicopter.
    we'll have the A-Team old cast (minus Hannibal) as a group of GB's enemies.
    and we'll have a bigh lough on patrick's face because this IS NOT TRUE!
  • Patrick
    The trailer is online, so you will look silly when the film comes out in 2009, It will be here, check out the trailer, its online, the projectors were broken at comic con, but now its on youtube. youtube.com/watch?v=cv39_qiltG8
  • JESUS LOPEZ
    what ever, is a stupid rumor, yea i agree , ghostbusters 1 and 2 was fun, but if this rumor is true , the old guys need another team of ghostbusters, this film need to much action. this is my idea respect to cast,
    new ghostbusters : silvester stallone, arnold s, bruce willis, and wesley snipes. this cast it's terrific.
    like satan,lucifer or diablo , chamuco : al pacino
  • Alfie
    I think they should have a story where Winston (being the only one who looks the same as he did 25 years ago) sets out to train the ghostbusters up to their former selves, however after a while they decide to hire a bunch of new ghostbusters. Just any good young actors/comedians, then they will most likely stay on for more films. Then winston can show em the ropes while the others do all the work that involves no physical exercise, like find
  • wesley
    well looks like its coming soon. i wonder what the author of this feels like now?
  • NoLie
    I'm half/half about recasting. On one side I can't see anyone other than the original cast play their roles in GB3 and a failed movie will screw up the franchise like with Iniana Jones and Star Wars. It just doesn't feel right as a huge GB fan to take that chance. But... On the other side, if done right and new GB movie would be awesome! Besides, why not take advantage of a potentially great franchise? If its done as a "pass-the-torch" sorta way it would make fans judge their "replacements" too much. Maybe just a new crew with new characters should be the way to go. Keep it GB at its core but let the new actors (whoever they may be) be themselves. I don't know about you but I'd be a lot less critical of them and might even enjoy them. I think the writers can take more risks with the movie if taken in this light. Either way, if GB3 is made it BETTER be great. Good just won't cut it with this fan. If not, scrap it and spare me the heartache.
blog comments powered by Disqus