According to Judge, “Monsignor Martinez” was going to be sillier than “King of the Hill” would have allowed him to be, adding, “The script for that pilot is funnier than any of the bits we did for ‘King of the Hill’ with [Monsignor Martinez], although those were just, like, short little pops [...] it’s something that every few years we talk about again as something that maybe we should try to do something with.”