Pierre Morel Reveals Dune Plans - He Wants 3D

Pierre Morel has revealed both his aspirations for Dune and some of the practical challenges he’ll face in realising it.

Apparently, he’s keen for the film to be in 3D and he’ll push for the format but the decision is yet to be made. So far he’s seen Avatar in 3D twice, he says, and it seems he’d like a little of that for his own project.

While development is continuing apace, work on the screenplay pages has yet to begin. The story is that Morel and his, as yet unnamed writer or writers, will start scripting in February. Are they keeping his collaborators secret? Or have they simply not hired anybody yet?

There’s a lot of good little bits and pieces in the interview. Morel is particularly interesting on the slow-built effect of David Lynch’s visionary jumble:

It’s tricky. Everybody refers to both the book and to David Lynch’s film, which was in a way a monument to the ’80s. It became a huge event. It didn’t do well theatrically, I think, but in a way it kind of marked and printed an image on Dune. Everybody now who reads Dune reads it with David Lynch’s images in mind.

So we have to get away from that. It’s not a remake of David Lynch’s movie. We’re doing a re-reading, a brand new approach on the book, a very true approach to the book, the original material. So we will have to deal with trying to erase the image that David Lynch did so we can propose our image.

Morel was speaking to IGN, presumably during the From Paris With Love press events.

Nothing will replace Lynch’s epic confusion in my affections, I’m sure, but it sure would be nice to see a different Dune, different even from Herbert’s book and certainly more compact than the Sci-Fi miniseries.
Related Posts with Thumbnails

  • Kaya
    I loved the book. I am on Dune Messiah now!! I'm hoping to read the whole series!!!
  • Bart
    The Book is epic! Taking on the job of turning it into a movie that will erase memories of Lynch's translation of the book is however...epic too!
    I hope for the love of the novell that he will succeed, and leaves room ( read:cash ) for sequals.
    It would be a terrible waste to see the Dune saga end at the end of book 1.
    I'm really looking forward to this translation of Herberts fantasy, with or without 3D effects.
    jmtc
  • greggorybasore
    I can't help but wonder what 3D could be used for with Paul's prescient visions of the future. That could produce some cool looking stuff.
  • RB
    Is it still newsworthy when a movie is being made into 3D, especially a sci-fi movie? After "Avatar" and it's bazillions made with a "3D tax", I'm surprised when a major tentpole ISN'T 3D. Heck, I'm a little surprised they're not trying to do something weird like convert the "Sex And The City" sequel to 3D just for the extra cash they'd make.
  • GxAce
    If you want a story go read the book, the movie should be about the visuals, or at least I believe they should be thought about first. This is not to say forget about the story, its just that visuals and sound are what differentiate movies from books. It seems that people forget that film is a VISUAL medium first everything else is secondary. Also imagery can tell a story too you know. They don't say "A picture is worth a thousand words" for nothing.
  • iec
    Yeah, cinematography can do a lot to tell a story. That has nothing to do with visual spectacle. Mindless visual spectacle is just mindless visual spectacle. Why rip off the story, premise, and ideas of a writer superior to you just so you can make money off of the possible visuals that they made up as well? Oh right, because it's profitable -- duh!
  • Bruce
    Wow... 3D. Way to ignore the story, themes and characters and focus on the visuals. Goddamn James Cameron and his gimmick.
  • MonsterKilledThePilot
    It just scares me that filmmakers have another thing to think about (3D) when its already an enormous challenge to make a good movie.
  • Hope he rethinks the techno-pop (ornithopters, wierding modules, etc.). Lynch's vision (though I agreed conceptually therewith--having read all books in the series prior to) had too much Lynch, in my opinion and the vaginal-mouthed spice-altered bodies of the Guild Navigators didn't really need to be that deformed; just seemed like Lynch was having a happy moment of SFX playtime. However, NOTHING will ever top Virgina Madsen as the captivating Princess Irulan. Where was HER vagina mouth ;P
  • Matthew
    If this is in 3D, its a given that they'll remove all the interesting ideas and drama involving religion, politics, ecology to instead focus on action and set pieces than the real story at heart.
  • RB
    I agree, but I think that was going to happen anyway, 3D or no 3D. From day on they've been saying that they'll be focusing on the action/adventure part of the book and not the "boring" parts.

    I'm one of the people who think the book is somewhat unfilmable. I think the only way to truly do justice to it would be as a 10-13 episode TV season. Even so, the sci-fi version a few years back was horrible. They went for style over substance. But at least they got some of the of the book across to a general audience.
  • Mook
    Typical internet moron making blind assumptions before page one of the script has even been written. Vote him up, ignorant jackasses.
  • iec
    No one produces in 3D if there's not the action for it, which means the premise of the film will be more about action than story. Everyone tried to defend Avatar's story before it came out with the same bullshit claim -- "You don't know! The story could be great!"

    Yes. Yes I do know. I know. It is known to me. The end.
  • SadiZombie
    Wow. You and Slatters are a couple of douche bags, eh? 3-D is about as impressive as watching a snail contemplate which direction it wants to go. There hasn't been a successful interpretation of Dune yet. So we'll just use the latest gimmick to give it a shine and hopefully draw in a lot of money on it's first weekend.
  • Slatters
    With such terrible source material to draw from, I'm not surprised that the adaptations have been so shitty.
  • Slatters
    Careful now, you're using too much logic here! That just won't fly well around these parts, Mister!
  • SD
    How is that? Just cause it's is 3D doesn't mean what makes Dune, Dune will be taken out?
  • Quich
    Being a big fan of the book and wanting to see a new film adaption, I love the fact that there has been so much news on this lately.
  • Slatters
    The book is so terrible. I'm glad that there's news about something other then Avatar, but my god, ha, the book... ugh. Laughable.
  • iec
    You're stupid. Dune is at the top of great sci-fi classics. I haven't read it, it's kind of dense, but to say it's terrible is just stupid. The series in all has done well, and a lot of the thought behind it is brilliant.

    Your post is indeed pointless. "Oo, I hate this book. Hey everyone, I hate it!"
  • Slatters
    This isn't a Dune fan board, if you want to wax idiotic about Dune then head to one of the many embarrassing fan forums dedicated to it.

    I read the book because someone convinced me it was some kind of seminal piece of literature. Why did I read it if it sucked so bad? How the hell would I be able to tell if it sucked if I HADN'T read it?
  • iec
    I did indeedy just write Snake instead of Snape.

    Crossover series between Metal Gear Solid and Harry Potter, of course.
  • Slatters
    "I haven't read it"

    "to say it's terrible is just stupid."

    In other words, you have nothing of any kind of validity to say on the matter? Yeah, thats what I thought.
  • iec
    You're still being a moron.

    Validity: people love the fucking book. End of story. You're the kind of person to run into a Harry Potter forum yelling "Snake killed Dumbledore, these books suck!"

    Why'd you read the book if it sucked so much?
  • Why did you bother to write this.
    Was it simply to shit like an asshole on Quich's comment and the taste of millions of people who have read and enjoyed this book over the last half century.
    Do you have any substance to offer the conversation?
  • Slatters
    If my comment was so entirely devoid of substance, what does that make your careful dissection of it?
  • Vinyard
    Translation: "He wants 3D" = he wants money.
  • vva
    Well duh! You think he's making the movie so it DOESN'T make money. Frank Herbert wrote Dune to make money as well.
  • No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money
  • Vinyard
    That's exactly what I was thinking! D'uh.
blog comments powered by Disqus