cormac_mccarthy

Author Cormac McCarthy gives very few interviews. So when he does sit down and talk with someone, the result is usually worth a look. Now, as the film version of his novel The Road is rolling out, McCarthy and director John Hillcoat have done a few brief talks. It’s really McCarthy’s show, as Hillcoat just interjects a question or observation here and there. After the break, check out what the reclusive author has to say about the film version of All the Pretty Horses, the potential movie of Blood Meridian, and the end of the world.

The Wall St. Journal talked to McCarthy about his life, his work and outlook on existence. But let’s do the strictly film-related stuff first. There is a possible film adaptation of the violent and grim Blood Meridian in the offing, once with Ridley Scott directing, now with Todd Field writing and directing. That is, if a screenplay can be assembled from the novel’s collection of odd characters and incidents. With respect to Blood Meridian being an impossible adaptation, McCarthy is dismissive:

That’s all crap. The fact that’s it’s a bleak and bloody story has nothing to do with whether or not you can put it on the screen. That’s not the issue. The issue is it would be very difficult to do and would require someone with a bountiful imagination and a lot of balls. But the payoff could be extraordinary.

He also doesn’t pull punches when talking about previous adaptations of his work. Not that he seems to actively dislike Billy Bob Thornton’s adaptation of All the Pretty Horses, but he’s not in love with it, either.

It could’ve been better. As it stands today it could be cut and made into a pretty good movie. The director had the notion that he could put the entire book up on the screen. Well, you can’t do that. You have to pick out the story that you want to tell and put that on the screen. And so he made this four-hour film and then he found that if he was actually going to get it released, he would have to cut it down to two hours.

There’s a lot more in the interview, and I recommend the whole thing. In an age of would-be celebrities that fawn at the media and spew rote positive bullshit just so they don’t accidentally make anyone mad, McCarthy feels like an amazing breath of fresh air. You’ve got to love a guy who creates stories for a living who is this pessimistic about where the glut of media is taking us:

Just the appalling volume of artifacts [like movies, etc.] will erase all meaning that they could ever possibly have. But we probably won’t get that far anyway.

  • snakedawgg
    In terms of Blood Meridian, the big question is still regarding who would play the character of Judge Holden. I can't really name any actor who can pull off the role. No one can even fit the physical profile of a seven foot, 350 pound and hairless albino. Let alone, the acting chops needed for that role...

    Roger Ebert, who is a big fan of Blood Meridian and McCarthy, has recommended Tom Noonan (Manhunter, House of the Devil) for the role. He's got the height. I also think he's got the acting chops. But he's too old, and not fat enough.

    So who is to play Judge Holden? Are the filmmakers supposed to pull a Dr. Manhattan on him and have him animated with CGI?
  • prat
    I fking loved the Road and Blood Merdian.
    I never read No Country for Old Men, but it was an awesome movie.
  • mikeFLA
    the lead sing of the great band lucero, wrote a concept album about the blood meridian. its call "the last pale light in the west". its very good, and if a movie is made it would be a shame if it didnt make the soundtrack.
  • RussFischer
    The great band Earth also used Blood Meridian inspiration on their record Hex: Or Printing in the Infernal Method. Jim Jarmusch used some of the Hex material in the soundtrack to The Limits of Control.
  • Stunsail
    Someone on IMDb suggested it and now it seems perfect: Alfred Molina for the Judge.
  • svart aske
    Height and size can easily be created through photography and digital manipulation, a la LOTR. As for who's suited to play the Judge, I think the British actor John Sharian fits the role. His character of Ivan in The Machinist is similarly creepy and supernatural; he also reminds one of Brando's Colonel Kurtz.

    I think the biggest problem with adapting Blood Meridian is that the novel itself does not have a strong plot. There's not much besides a lot of wandering and killing that drives the story. I loved the book, but mainly for McCarthy's incredible writing and the rich biblical/literary references.
  • Of course there is a plot. The young man's babtism into the world by blood. His lightness and reproach compared to the judges darkness. These men are basically hired to rid the desert of the Apache war band terrorizing the settlers and villagers. They become blood drunk after vanquishing the first war band. Then the party becomes gold and scalp hungry. The plot is the young mans inner turmoil. I see many allusions with the Eqyptian Sekhmet, and they must face their equal fate as they live by the sword. The Kid's redemption is absolute. The Judge is a complicated character to manifest, how do you pull him in? His lineage seems to draw forth from a lot of different brands of secret schools of thought which will leave an average film goer scratching their heads he is a sociopath, a pedophile, and seems to have his own interpratation of ethics and moral dogma; masonic, gnostic, ect. I think another real issue in filming is how to illustrate a solid back story in a short enough space to draw an uninitiated audience in. I feel a four hour epic feature with intermissions, while being a thing of the past, may be required to fully tell the story. I think Alfred Molina would be great for the Judge or Maury Chaykin.
  • [A]
    Seriously, Cormac McCarthy is the man.
  • freemachine
    I hope to one day see BBT's 4-hour cut of All The Pretty Horses. The theatrical cut is still very watchable; great performances and directing.
  • I have read blood meridian and yes, the violence is as you say real world. It's quite something to read. That being said, I don't think it was any more gratuitous than anything that has been in any saw or hostel movie, or even inglorious basterds. I agree though that it would be a tough sell to have a studio make it. For those that don't know, and I'm sure I'm going to butcher this because its been a while since I read it, The BASICS of the novel are that the main character joins a group of cowboys who have learned that the Mexican government is paying for Apache scalps, and wants some of the action. It doesn't take them long to learn that a scalp is a scalp and the mexicans wont be able to tell the difference. So they just slaughter everything they get near, including, and this is the bad part, infants. So there you go, bad stuff. Well written book regardless, brad does a much better job explaining it if you follow his link to the old story. Sorry for the novel.
  • BrokenHelix79
    I apologize for this not being on-topic, per se, but I couldn't help but notice your comment is simply copied and pasted from Brad Brevet's site over at Rope of Silicon.

    What's up with that?
  • c_los
    I posted this on imdb, but my pick for Holden is Kerry Shook.

    http://blogs.lifeway.com/blog/edstetzer/blogima...
  • The Man
    Danny DeVito as the judge. Epic.
  • Bull
    Billy Zane or Ernest Borgnine as Judge Holden. Only two actors who could possibly pull the role off.
  • Ronnie Ridge
    They need to make the film.
    I think Apocalypse Now is a good comparison, and perhaps a good reference point for anyone willing to take on McCarthy's book. Both have an hallucinatory effect with both story and violence. Both have a bald headed madman. Kurtz and the Judge have a lot of similarities.
  • Brendan
    Imagine Brando as the Judge... !
  • tmw
    The thing that most people see to forget is that it hs less to do with: bald, fat, tall, pale, etc ...

    What needs to be remembered are these 2 fundamental qualities:
    -2) The Smiling. Alot. And almost NOTHING gets to him EVER. It's a kind of villian we don't see too much of. He's not the cranky/ psychotic/ rash or calm/ cool/ evil genius archtype, tho he actually IS more of the latter.

    But he's one of those types of people that we've all known and/or met. The type that rarely have a stupid grin leave their face. A permgrin.

    2) He's described (by Tobin, I believe) as being "both completely insane yet completely sane at once"


    So, who might be able to do that needs to convey a sense of utter ease and confidence.


    John Lithgow (baby faced, tall, commanding, can do evil)
    Benizio Del Toro (crazy and scary)
    Kevin Durand (kind of grinny, intimidating, good voice/ prescence)
    Emmett Walsh (weird, scary but maybe too old)
blog comments powered by Disqus