Pixar's up glasses

The best animated feature Oscar is a category that has been limited in the past few years to only three nominees. At least sixteen films must be submitted each year to push the category to include five nominated films. This year, for the first time since the category was created in 2001, the Academy has twenty submissions for the category, and with the list in hand the race for Best Animated Film just got interesting.

I’m not an Oscar guy, so I’m not going to waste your time here with empty prognostications about what films out of this roster of twenty might actually be nominated, and which should win. (Though Up seems like a clear front-runner in both cases.) But looking at the list below, what you’ll see is that there are more than five pictures that could be nominated to make a very interesting race. Again, that might be a moot point, thanks to the presence of Pixar’s Up.

Variety has the list of submitted films, which goes as follows:

Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel
Astro Boy
Battle for Terra
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs
Coraline
Disney’s A Christmas Carol
The Dolphin – Story of a Dreamer
Fantastic Mr. Fox
Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs
Mary and Max
The Missing Lynx
Monsters vs. Aliens
9
Planet 51
Ponyo
The Princess and the Frog
The Secret of Kells
Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure
A Town Called Panic
Up

A couple of these films might seem like unknowns. The Secret of Kells is what looks to be an interesting hand-drawn film about “a ninth-century boy who rebels against his guardian’s orders and helps to illuminate a famous Irish manuscript.” The film has drawn great reviews at festivals and overseas. The trailer is below.

And The Missing Lynx is a Spanish-made CGI film about “an endangered feline trying to evade a big-game hunter.” The trailer is also embedded below.

Without having seen a few of the yet to be released films on the list, there’s still a very good shortlist of five nominees that jumps out. A year in which Coraline, Fantastic Mr. Fox, Mary & Max, Ponyo and Up are in the running is a very good one. Fans of A Town Called Panic will want to see that among the nominees, and I can see why. There’s still a qualifying run in LA that must take place for that film and a few others, but barring any problems there, the race should be a good one.

  • Maracle2
    i think UP will win but it would be cool to see Coraline pull an upset.
  • tommy
    Why is Tinkerbell near anything considered "award worthy"?
  • i agree, but i would put it above alvin and the chipmunks...
  • fdfa
    I'd like to think that the creators know damn well that they won't win, but submit just to see the category expand. Probably not true, but meh
  • DRF
    Coraline. Up would've been good as a live action film. Coraline did things in the animated realm that make it impossible to think of the story being told any other way.
  • Coraline got my pick. Up was good, but Coraline really captured animation.
  • Jezza
    There will be 5 nominations because of Rober Zemeckis allowing A Christmas Carol to be shortlisted. The Academy loves Robert Zemeckis.
    If anyone can beat Pixar it's Robert Zemeckis.

    I bet in 2000 if Soderbough wasn't nominated twice he would have been the director line up.

    Ridley Scott: Gladiator
    Ang Lee: Croutching Tiger Hidden Dragon
    Steven Soderbough: Traffic
    Steven Daldry: Billy Elliot
    Robert Zemeckis: Cast Away
  • lipslikeasukal
    I'm a Pixar fanboy, but I'd have to go with Coraline. Beautiful animation and a fun story.

    But then again, Alvin and the Chipmunks seems to be the only movie there with a pun in its title so I'll call it a draw.
  • benu
    "Secret of Kells" is an absolutely beautiful film. I surely hope it gets a nomination. The idea right now for a US release is an Academy qualifying run in LA in December and a wider release in March.
  • Maughtry
    With more slots for "Best Picture" open would it be possible to see something like 'Up' compete for that and be left out of this animation race altogether? It couldn't compete in both... could it?
  • In theory it perfectly could. If it gets a nom consider it case closed for best animated film.
  • nomiko
    Actually no it cannot. A film can only be submitted for one category. If it has been submitted for consideration to Best Animated, it cannot be considered for Best Picture as well.
  • That is simply wrong. The following quote is from the rules page for the oscars on oscars.org.

    Rule 7. III. F.

    Films submitted in the Animated Feature Film category may qualify for Academy Awards in other categories, including Best Picture, provided they comply with the rules governing those categories.
  • JNS
    It's really a toss up between Coraline and Up for me. I think there's a chance one of the foreign films could supplant Princess and the Frog in the nominees.
  • Gary
    Up was good, but we need a fresh win. Pixar shouldn't have won for Wall-E so, yeah... Fantastic Mr Fox... and I haven't even seen it yet.
  • What should have beat Wall-E.
  • nolacuse
    WALL-E shouldn't have won? What should have? Kung-Fu Panda? I think not.
  • GreatBigLion
    Predictions for Nominees:
    Fantastic Mr. Fox
    Ponyo
    The Princess and the Frog
    A Town Called Panic
    Up (Most Likely To Win)
  • Up is good and all, but I'm rooting for Coraline (I have a soft-spot for spot motion)
  • Palmer
    What the hell is Alvin and the Chipmunks doing in that list?
  • Craigasorusrex
    My thoughts exactly.
  • Reese
    This was a pretty great year for animation (Coraline, Ponyo, Mary and Max were all great) but the Academy should probably just hand the Oscar over to UP now and save everyone the time and trouble.

    Of course, UP may sneak into the Best Picture nominees instead, which may prove interesting.
  • Sarzy
    Yeah, seriously. Sucks to be any of the other nominees this year. Considering the fact that Pixar films have won four out of the six times they've been nominated, and Up is widely considered to be Pixar's best film, I'd say the odds of Up winning are pretty much 99%.
  • JNS
    Fantastic Mr. Fox may be a good movie, but the animation looks sophmoric.
  • cheshireana
    I agree. I'm just so put off of seeing it by how choppy the animation looks.
  • Nick1
    Is Alvin and the Chipmunks even eligible? It's partially CGI, of course, but lots of it is live action, including most of the backgrounds.

    Not that it would ever, ever, even possibly be close to be considered to be possible in a million years even if there were no other films to be nominated, to being nominated, but I still wonder.
  • medicalmarajuana
    Up, Ponyo, Coraline, Fantastic Mr. Fox, and either Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs, Princess and the Frog, or the Secret of Kells will be nominated. Strong pack of animated films this year.
  • dagreenman18
    I can guess 4 of the short list: Coraline, Up, Ponyo, and Fantastic Mr. Fox. Hopefully Princess and the Frog is worthy.

    And everyone needs to go and hunt down a copy of Secret of Kells. It's freaking awesome and beautiful to look at.
  • Ben
    I liked up, but I think the amazing opening montage really carried up the rest of the movie. I enjoyed Coraline much more. I wasn't really interested in seeing it, but I was glued to the TV the whole time. Really just an amazing experience.
  • Yes! I knew Kells'd make it, if I got it right.
    Saw this at the premiere. Fantastic movie. And a nice fantasy take on the origin of the book of Kells.

    Since most of you haven't seen it, you probably wouldn't know it should be up there with Coraline and Up.
    But ehh. It'll get a theatrical release Jan 2010. You'll see then.
  • Joe Glou
    Mark my words : Mary & Max !
    The guy who did it, already won an Oscar for his short and I think everybody at the Academy is just fed up with Pixar winning each and every year...

    (if not Mary and Max, Coraline, but no way Up is getting it. No. Way.)
  • Garber
    I don't think anybody at the Academy is fed up with handing out awards to the same people over and over. I mean Sean Penn wins Oscars seemingly year after year for any given performance, mediocre or otherwise.

    Pixar's the best in their field, unlike many, their work deserves award recognition. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they lose at the Annies Awards again, since they do seem to genuinely be a bunch of jealous losers.
  • Sobchak
    I think that if Princess and the Frog turns out to be watchable, and makes some good money at the box office, then it will upset (the probably Best Picture-nominated anyway) Up to take the prize. Remember that a traditional Disney animated picture has never won this award.
  • Weyland_Yutani
    probably right on this. Princess and the Frog isn't this blog's cup of tea, but there is a good chance it scores heavily with wide audiences if it pulls some strings. If it works, Disney will be legit pick for the award. Hard to say though.

    I'm picking Coraline at this point. Well deserving.
  • Jezza
    Motion Capture movies have never won it in the past either.
  • Jarryd
    I have the same questions as everyone else on this list. 1. How does Alvin & the Chipmunks qualify because I think Avatar would be more fitting for this category then Alvin & the Chipmunks. 2. How does Tinkerbell get a chance at being nominated when it is Direct to DVD? All I can say is Fox and Disney have wasted some money for even trying with those two.
  • tedulous
    1. Alvin and the Chipmunks' characters are mostly animated, thus 20th Century Fox decided to submit it as animated. I'm sure James Cameron would throw a fit if they did the same thing with Avatar.
    2. Tinkerbell had its one-week run at the El Capitan in Hollywood in advance of its DVD release.
    The thing is... all the studios have been trying to get the number of nominees to 16 (which they actually passed decisively) in order to get 5 nominees and helping the chances for their other animated movies.
  • Danisgod6491
    Coraline or Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs should win.
  • starscream9289
    Alvin and the Chipmunks?

    BUAHAHAHAHAHA!
  • tedulous
    My five nominees:
    Up
    Coraline
    The Fantastic Mr. Fox
    Ponyo
    The Princess and the Frog

    Up also will get nominated for Best Picture... but will only win Animated Feature
  • Alex
    Doesn't matter. Up will win and it's no contest. Up will also get a Best Picture nomination.
  • doogleberrywinkler
    "Mary and Max" should make the nominated list. It seems to have reviewed roughly on par with "Up" on Rotten Tomatoes as well (albeit with fewer reviews counted). However the reviews seem more glowing in their praise. Not forgetting, the director has already won an Academy Award for his previous effort in claymation (in the shorts category), and that critics generally go ga-ga over quality clay animation pieces nearly as much as they do Pixar works.
  • shora_f
    Really?? Everyone??? Why nobody even mentions Cloudy with a Chance of meatballs???

    That was literally the best animated thing I've seen since The Incredibles... seriously!! Nothing has dropped my jaw visually this year as much as that... and I hate seeing all the awesome efforts of Sony Animation or other studios just being ignored because Pixar keeps getting more recognition based on their 5-year old efforts. Not just visually, but story wise the movie was brilliant and all the jokes worked.

    Up! was solid and all, but it really falls apart in the last two acts and even last year, Panda was much more worthier to win it than Wall-E (go check the Annie awards who's given out by real animation people)

    This Pixar suck-up-ness really is getting to a lot of us animation people.
    and no... I don't work for Sony Animation.

    Anyway, I have not seen all these movies... but based on all I can see and the way all these old-ass critics go ga-ga for anything CG-less:

    Mary and Max
    Caroline
    Up!
    Ponyo
    toss up between Secret of Kells and Princess and Frog (based on how well it does)

    It's really a shame
  • YazzyDream
    From the movies I have seen I'd want Coraline to win. 9 is up there as well as Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs.

    Up was really neat, but that third act was really juvenile.

    Still need to see the movies yet to be released, Mary and Max, and a Town Called Panic.
  • malars
    Wasn't 'Battle for Terra' the worst box office bomb of all time (or very close to it)? Not that this should have any bearing on a nomination, but I wouldn't think the studio would be rushing out to get a nomination for the film unless they just added that to the list to get an increase to five films so another film from said studio could get some face time come awards season. Curious...
  • 71Makaveli96
  • evilninjax
    Is there no Love for MARY AND MAX? That film was as funny, touching, and beautiful as any I've seen this year and maybe the past several years.
  • Petteri.
    Im totally with you on this.
    Mary and Max is beautiful. Lots of heart in that one.

    For me these are the noms:

    Up
    Coraline
    Mary and Max
    Fantastic Mr. Fox
    Ponyo

    Although I think probably (and that would be great), The Secret of Kells gets one instead of... maybe Ponyo? don't know about that. Pretty hard this year to pick the nominees.

    Certainly... I think Up will win. And I loved it, don't get me wrong, but Mary and Max is simply beautiful, and would be great to see that one getting the Oscar.
  • Golgo 13
    CORALINE CORALINE CORALINE CORALINE CORALINE
  • DonRoritor
    Up should be nominated for best picture, leaving the others to compete for best animated picture.

    I'd be ok with Coraline or Ponyo or Mary and Max winning, as long as whatever wins doesn't have anthropomorphic characters dancing to 90s club songs or playing Axel F as a punchline.
blog comments powered by Disqus