No Dark Tower For J.J. Abrams

dark_tower_1

I keep thinking that the idea that J.J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof would be adapting Stephen King’s epic Dark Tower series was commonly understood as a dead deal. The last time Lindelof spoke about the project, in October, seemed pretty definitive: “My guess is they will get made because they’re so incredible. But not by me.” Now J.J. Abrams has weighed in on the subject with his own statement that is sure to crush the hearts of hopeful King fans everywhere.

MTV spoke to Abrams, who said “The Dark Tower thing is tricky. It’s such an important piece of writing. The truth is that Damon and I are not looking at that right now.”

I’ll take issue with ‘important’, but ‘tricky’ is definitely right. This is a story that very much lives on the page, and to put it on screen would have required an insane commitment, either to make multiple films or a long television show. I would have been intrigued to see how that worked out — I’m always fascinated by super-ambitious adaptations — but not all that optimistic. Creating a successful movie or television series on the scale The Dark Tower, even with King’s large readership to (possibly) rely on, seems like a real long shot.

This whole thing is amusing, because even when the project seemed like a theoretical possibility Lindelof was hedging his comments. Reading between the lines of comments he made a year ago, it seems like there was no real idea of how to make the thing work.

Almost makes you wonder if King sold the option to these guys just so it would be off the table for everyone else and he could get a break from hearing bogus pie in the sky offers. Unlikely, I know, but that’s the sort of thing I’d expect someone to do if they knew a project was basically hopeless from the start.

  • MonsterKilledThePilot
    They've already done an amazing job with LOST. They dont need to adapt the Dark Tower. Someone call Frank Darabont.
  • therealribbit
    Sounds like the best news i've heard all year.
  • I really wish this wasn't true. I thought when I first herd JJ and co were involved, it would get done and start movement soon. Now I can only see Darabont doing it and King already said he didn't want him doing the adaptation. Plus I really wouldn't want Frank getting away from The Walking Dead TV series right now, I mean we don't need two great stories shelved because someone won't do the job the first time.
  • Allm0st
    Thank God this isn't happening yet. Love the books but I couldn't imagine how it could be put into a film. It's one of my favorite series but just can't see it hitting the big screen anytime soon, possibly at all. It took King 34 years to complete the series I just can't see it becoming a movie really.
  • Really? The whole story played out well to me like a very long film. Yes, it did take King a long time to finish it but it was only because he was doing other books and stuff like that. I think if he wanted to, he could have finished it closer to the release of the first book.

    I liked the books too and I could see JJ Abrams bringing it to life. To tell you the truth, I actually saw it as a TV series, possibly on Showtime, that would take one book and tell the story in the span of one season. It would work but we're not so sure Westerns are working right now. It's possible to make it but it has to find an audience first other than us, the fans.
  • Allm0st
    As the man said below whom you also responded to, the books get crazy around five and Stephen King actually put himself into the story. To me 1-4 were the best books 5-7 was just filling in the gap to me at least and man did the ending suck but King said he couldn't think of any other way to end it. And no Westerns really aren't working right now I remember it was either HBO or Showtime that had a Western show that only had a few seasons though wasn't that bad. But my reason for not seeing it come to life is it would have to be changed a lot and then it would lose some fan base, then the people who haven't read the books wouldn't understand some of it.
    I would like to see it but can't see it coming to life and sure Abrams could if he wanted to but it would be a bigger risk than rebooting the Star Trek franchise. That's my opinion though lol hell I would love to see it done almost exactly by the books with things changed for the better, but I don't know just always seemed unlikely to me.
  • cambion
    I agree with seeing it as a Showtime series, but I don't think it would take a whole season to do one book. I think you could get the first 2 books into one season pretty easily, then a book and a half per season after that.

    I don't see it working as a movie series. Too long with too many logistical problems and not a big enough audience built-in. King is one of the few mega-selling authors who's movies are in no way guaranteed to be hits.
  • Jon DuBB
    Super lame. Well, at least they aren't going to do it because they knew they couldn't.
  • Brian
    I think it'd be good if they did something like the Dark Tower comic series and just add to the series rather than redo it.
  • immature
    The series falls apart at book 5. How would they have dealt with book 7's lame ending or the lamer Crimson King?
  • ---------------POSSIBLE SPOILERS-------------------

    Yes, the Crimson King was kinda lame at the end of the series but given a great spin and making him darker would be a plus in order to achieve the kind of villain we'd want to see. Also, I would love to see the "ending" play out somehow when Roland finally enters the tower.
  • GORT
    If there is anyone who could have done this movie justice it would be Lindelof. He is a true fan of the series and would not ruin it. Just hope the series does not land in the lap of some hack. I heard that Lindelof wanted to the first book of the series 'The Gunslinger' as one movie which probably did not go too well with the studio as very little happens in that first book both plotwise and action wise. Could that be the reason this whole thing fell apart?
  • jasonb26
    dude, "the man in black fled across the desert, and the gunslinger followed" is a legendary opening line of modern storytelling.

    this is an important piece of literature, hands down. a SHO/HBO/AMC series would've been a dream come true. limit it to 6 or 7 seasons, like lost, and we'd have a masterpiece.
  • sauce_1
    The Only way to take these books and put them on screen is to have HBO or Showtime make a mini-series. But there's No way in hell you're gonna be able to make these into episodic one hour shows over 4-5 seasons. It's too large a project for that and the story would never be able to be chopped into tiny segments like that. A mini-series with 120 minute chunks of the story told at a time are the way to go. Think of it as the Fantasy/Western/Horror version of Band o Brothers. Then you could get a number of different directors to contribute, as they did on B. of B., then each piece of the story could have it's own unique feel as they do in the books.

    Then again, I have doubts it will ever make it to the screen in any form.
  • Chris
    This is quite possibly my favorite book. And I was soooo dissapointed to hear JJ isn't doing it, he would have made it great. I would just like to see it on a SCREEN, in some kind of media, i don't care what. I think it CAN be done in a movie, if done right. It CANNOT be done in any less then 6 movies. And it couldn't be done in any less then 4 seasons of a TV series, depending on # of Episodes. This will be popular no matter what, with Stephen King's Audience, and the current craze for EPIC movies, this could be a master piece if in the right hands.

    Please make this into something, I want to WATCH it!
  • gigaherc
    I HATE YOU JJ!!

    Jeezz, I had such high hopes... If he makes another Mission Impossible with crazy Tom or another Cloverfield crappy sequel I'm gonna hate him even more. He had a chance to make something really epic (I know the term is overused but DT series are EPIC), but form the quotes I read I think he's simply afraid.

    Noiw it's high time someone call Darabont (like some othe poster mentioned) because we have some really good time for post-apocalyptic themed movies coming, and there is a chance to make history with these movies.

    I think it's not too hard to put 7 books into a trilogy, I really don't like the idea of a hbo like TV series, the material needs a lot of effort and money indeed but it's not impossible.

    Hell, JJ you just made my day shitty.From now on I'm gonna download all your movies and not give you a penny chicken shit! I prefer to pay Bay or buy all Boll DVD's than to see such a coward's movies in cinema!

    I know I got pissed excuse me.
  • bonowall
    I couldn't agree with you more...I just posted and it led to a JJ bash...Hollywood is becoming worse and worse with every sequel. But we go?! We go like lemmings off a cliff. For example...the 2.45 hr waste of film (or digital memory) that was Transformers 2....it's painfully shocking to me to see that box office take. I think JJ and Bay should play leads in a Thelma And Louise reboot!
  • I for one thoroughly enjoyed the ending to the whole thing. I'll take endings like that over the neat tidy bow endings like the one Harry Potter employed everyday of the week. Regardless, it would be tough adapting this series to film. The insertion of King himself into the narrative wouldn't work on film. (It barely worked in the book.) There's also the problem of adapting the fifth book would be yet another retelling of Seven Samurai. Also, what would you do with Father Callahan? Or all the other connections to King's other work? Again, these are things that would not work on film. It's a tough job. Still, I imagine we'll see an adaptation at some point. I hear fantasy series adaptations are popular these days.
  • bonowall
    Wow. First off, thanks for the scoop (though dissapointing)...I check the webs regularly to see if JJ has made any commented or hinted to updates and it all leads to this. Unbelievable!

    I am an avid LOST fan and I think JJ really came up with a great, transcendant show for the networks which can never be replicated well (cough cough...Flash Forward). Lindeloff and Cuse are great writers IMO and I thought that JJ and Lindeloff would really be able to flesh this complex series out.

    I agree with all other posters that this is a series that would either require a minimum of a trilogy on film or 4-7 season series arc on television and these days that is not easy to come by. Folks are talking about Darabont again and I automatically draw myself in the other direction, toward the only Director I know who has braved another amazingly complex series (which, at it's core, is the paralell to TDT)...Peter Jackson.

    I can see JJ and co waiting to see how Lucas sells his Star Wars live action material to a network and leverage that to work for TDT. Right now, that's the other thing i scan the webs for news on every day...

    I say SOMEONE should tackle this material and I thought JJ was the guy to do it. Nope. Instead, he is in the cash cow directors guild (sitting at the same creative table as Bay) rebooting, remaking, reimagining, and regurgitating material. So much for that great original concept of LOST...it looks like we won't see that or any other brevity from this director again. And, to make it worse, he is bringing Lindeloff in to the firey pits of Hell with him....Turn away Damon, stop the sequels.....make original content!!!!!!
  • jimmyjoe89
    Sad news:( I've been waiting Dark Tower movies for years now. I hope that Frank Darabont would be brave enough to take a risk and make those movies. I know that it will be hard project, but someone's have to do it. I love the books and I'd love to see the movies some day
  • This does suck, then again the books would be INCREDIBLY hard to translate to film. Still, I'd love to see someone try. I know Frank Darabont has expressed interested to King, but for some weird reason King wasn't so keen on the idea at the time. Hopefully now that the deal with JJ has kind of fell through, Darabont seizes the oppurtunity.
  • roxxy
    Maybe Stephen King thought that, if JJ Abrams is doing those films, it would be a sure blockbuster. As we know JJ is like a Midas, everything he touches turn into gold . Frank Darabont is a great director, but he's not the most famous director in Hollywood. Although who believed Peter Jackson when started filming LOTR-movies. I guess that most of the fans said that he's going to ruin the books by doing some stupid Hollywood crap movie.
  • daniel
    don't let this thing be restrained. there's a door. we're on the other side of it. go ahead big guy.
  • Annie
    as much as I would love to see a Dark Tower movie, I'm so afraid that it will get screwed up (like the end of The Mist) This was a HUGE undertaking by Abrams and I'm not surprised that he's possibly putting it aside for now. Let's wait and see what happens after the ending of Lost and the next Star Trek movie... hopefully they'll give it another chance.
blog comments powered by Disqus