bb1

For Hunter’s reviews/wrap-ups of the previous two episodes of Breaking Bad leading up to last Sunday’s divisive finale, click here for ep 11 (”Mandala”) and here for ep 12 (”Phoenix”).

Now that most everyone has caught up with the season finale of Breaking Bad, entitled “ABQ,” on their TiVo and what not, let’s take a look at what went…down. Actually, for the sake of disclosure, the mini-delay of this write-up is also due to the episode being a surprising disappointment in my eyes. For a series that is deftly founded on madcap realism, the natural awes of science, and the odds of consequence, I found “ABQ” to stretch way beyond the show’s established believability (and viewers’ trust therein).

Spoiler Alert from this point forward: While the ending to “ABQ” finally revealed the cause of the body bags and the doom-laden destruction at the Whites’ residence that we’ve gleaned all season long, it steered far, far away from fans’ countless predictions. Not a single commenter on /Film guessed that the ending would carry a strange, ill-fitting religious twist; complete with fire-and-brimstone imagery that instantly reminded me of those ludicrous Left Behind books. Yuck. That said, perhaps the only remaining loose-end from the finale is the pink teddy bear. You may recall that the stuffed bear appeared in the previous episode, “Phoenix,” during a drug transaction and yet it inexplicably appears here floating in Walt White’s pool. (This being an ominous image that was teased all season long.) There is no logical explanation. And don’t worry, there officially isn’t one. As you’ll read, a higher power most likely placed it there as a humorous cherry atop a vengeful sundae of “You’re Fucked, Walt.” Satisfying? Not at all.

I was curious to hear if the loud Biblical-like doom and destruction at the end of the finale was intentional. Maybe I was misinterpreting it, or over-analyzing a TV show that is stocked with talented writers who make sport of clever subtext. Thankfully, the show’s brilliant mastermind, Vince Gilligan, has been quite vocal about the finale. Unfortunately, he confirmed that what Walt encountered at season’s end was indeed “the wrath of God raining down,” or “Lucifer ex machina, ‘Devil from the machine’—it’s the opposite of [deus ex machina]. It almost could feel kind of random, but it’s not.” So, in the name of bad puns, Walt White wasn’t blinded by science at the end. No, in his world, the one Gilligan created, there are still bigger forces at play, like divine predestination. In Gilligan’s words, two airliners exploding over Walt’s head was no less than a “cosmic indictment” of his life’s misdirection. Jesse Pinkman, go ahead, say it: ”Yo!”

1

In Season Two—which, outside of Sunday’s finale, made for some of the greatest TV I’ve ever seen—I had previously noticed scenes with religious undertones and imagery. This was most notable and visible in episode nine, entitled “4 Days Out.” That fantastic ep found Walt White and Jesse Pinkman stranded in their mobile meth lab in the desert, suffering from dehydration and hunger. Jesse finally broke down over the steering wheel and began to quietly pray. If memory serves, he began to tear-up and apologize for wrongs he had committed. Jesse’s youthful regret was tinged with a real, mortal fear that most men only experience much later in life. And of course, there was nothing wrong with Jesse praying. But until this scene we had no reason to believe that Jesse (or the show itself) was religious.

This scene added another layer to Jesse, a character that had not only fallen on hard times (he was completely broke, car-less, and homeless), but had literally fallen into shit and piss (porta-potty, episode four, “Down,” gross). In a later episode this season, Jesse, again under pressure, clasped his hoodied-arms together to pray at the kitchen counter in his apartment. Maybe he chose to pray there because he thought his bong might serve as an intergalactic antenna. But as the stakes got higher to match the widening scope of Jesse and Walt’s drug business, I wondered if the role of “faith” and a forced notion of THE all-seeing eye would also become greater. I really, really hoped it would not go in that direction. With the DEA, competing dealers and organizations, and impossible amounts of stress gaining on Walt White, the show had no reason to bring a god into it. Alas, Gilligan’s explanation of the finale has given me pause. I’m left wondering if Breaking Bad was planned as a religious allegory; an overconfident man of science and math testing reality to such an extent that a higher power steps in and serves him up. I mean, the inclusion of an all-seeing eye belonging to a god might even put Saul Goodman out of business. The horror.

To Hit or Not To Hit Audiences and Walt Over the Head

In my write-up of “Phoenix,” the parallels between Jesse’s girlfriend, Jane Margolis, and Walt’s new baby daughter, Holly, were discussed. To reiterate, in “Phoenix” Walt is shown placing Holly onto her side like a loving parent. Later on, after Walt unknowingly and randomly encounters Jane’s father, Donald, at a bar, Walt asks his advice on how to raise a daughter. Donald, having just dealt with Jane’s latest and last relapse, offers a friendly shrug. Minutes later, Walt is standing over Jane as she chokes in her sleep on heroin-induced vomit, after he indirectly caused her to roll onto her back. If Walt had helped Jane by placing her on her side she likely would have survived. In his Q&A with viewers, Gilligan described the aforementioned parallels between Jane and Holly in “Phoenix” with this: “Those are the kinds of moments that you want to be subtle enough that they don’t hit you over the head. …There’s an idea there of the cycle of life. And it just seemed like a cool thing to do.”

But this sentiment doesn’t gel with “ABQ”—an episode that was uncharacteristically drenched in borderline melodrama. Here, the parallels-of-life between Holly and Jane are incredibly heavy-handed. After Jane’s father (actor John de Lancie) lays out Jane’s funeral dress on her bed, sleeves extended at the side to form a cross-like image, we cut to Holly, lying down with her arms extended out just the same. Geezus, we get it. In regards to Gilligan’s concern for beating us “over-the-head,” perhaps he should have better listened to Hank’s glorious speech about “wack-a-mole” in this ep. Because the whole beating-Walt-over-the-head-with-two-air-liners thing was even harder to swallow. It’s a bleak and ridiculous “cosmic” twist on par with a doctor—distraught over a dead daughter caught in mob crossfire—accidentally replacing Tony Soprano’s heart with an ape’s. And after Walt and Donald’s random if not far-fetched encounter in “Phoenix,” the culminating disaster is so fatalistically ludicrous so as to put their previous crossing of paths under a bullshit lamp. Feel free to disagree in the comments, or debate me directly on Twitter.

5

Jesse, Mike The Fixer, and the Post-Apocalyptic Ruins of Meth Country

While /Film was way off on predicting the bodies in the bodybags—re: passengers from the air-collision—we were close to being on the money about how Jesse and Walt would deal with Jane’s death. The episode opens with bouncing bed springs. Tasteful. Jesse is attempting to resuscitate Jane to no avail. Yep, so Jesse calls Walt who “calls Saul.” And Saul sends over a “fixer” or “a cleaner” a la Harvey Keitel’s Winston “The Wolf” in Pulp Fiction. As played by veteran actor, Jonathan Banks, Mike the Fixer is just as mysterious, professional, unmoved, and surprisingly likable as we could ever hope for a character in this line of work. (It would be great to see the character have a larger role in Season 3.) Mike drives to Jesse’s apartment and calmly yet briskly disposes of the needles, including the one Walt touched, in Jesse’s bedroom, and then confiscates Jesse’s bong and money (until the dust settles). He tells a shaken, disoriented Jesse to cover up his track marks, call 9-1-1 and play dumb. Tells him he’s almost in “the home stretch.” Jesse does what Mike says. “Playing dumb” is sadly not much of a stretch in his current state.

As we have come to expect, Jesse enters a druggy haze as he mourns the loss of his girlfriend. Walt has to call Mike to track Jesse down. They find Jesse strung out on heroin in a shanty-town of drug dens. These scenes, in which Walt walks up to and enters this drug zone, almost feel torn out of a post-apocalyptic sci-fi horror movie. Meth users stare eerily at, er, through, Walt like nocturnal, tribal-tatted zombies. He’s visibly unsettled by them, like a mad scientist seeing his creations in daylight. Once Walt finds him, Jesse (Aaron Paul) begins to sob uncontrollably, blaming himself and professing his love for Jane. To be honest, rather than strike up any real emotion, I found this scene to be overdone, as if bobbing for Emmys; moreover I found Jesse, my favorite character, pathetic.

Walt takes Jesse to a posh facility that looks like a tepee spa—note: shot lingering on the sky opening—straight out of Entourage. (I believe Walt mentions this kooky place in Season One per his cancer treatment/newfound ability to lie to his wife?) For now, Jesse seems safe, able to sweat, think, and mourn out a lot of the dread and anxiety plaguing him throughout the season. It’s here that most viewers knew Jesse wouldn’t end up in one of the body bags. A little relief.

7

Skyler Don’t Play That

Before the sky erupts into flame directly over Walt’s head, he is left behind by his family. While in the hospital awaiting surgery (successful), Walt is hopped up on pain killers and groggily reveals to Sklyer (and an ever-doting Walt Jr.) that he does indeed own two cell phones. Hell hath no fury. All season long, we’ve anticipated Skyler cheating on Walt with her corrupt former and current boss Ted Beneke. She hasn’t, and I think this was a great creative decision. Of the show’s adults, Skyler remains the most morally upstanding, and in a TV landscape where ladies (and men) are increasingly promiscuous, the character, as played by Anna Gunn, remained strong and independent without sinking to Walt’s lows and appetite for power, selfishness, and lies.

An undetermined amount of time has passed since Walt’s surgery (he now has an unfetching fuzz on his chin). Skyler confronts Walt as she hastily packs. She’s leaving him to stay indefinitely with Hank and her sister. Skyler tells him that she knows about the two phones; she also reveals to Walt that he’s paid for his cancer treatments in full without assistance (but she knows not how he did this, which has to be maddening given the sum). She also knows that Walt never visited his mother (whom we haven’t met). Moreover, his mother didn’t even know Walt had cancer (but now she seemingly does; that has to hurt).

If it wasn’t for the birth of Holly, a divorce might be inevitable. Walt’s deceit and secrecy this season has reached its limit, and in one of the best scenes all season, Skyler tells Walt that she no longer wants to know. She’s scared to know the truth. The truth is, she doesn’t know her husband or the father of her children at all. This season, the relationship between Walt and Skyler has been dreadfully cold—maybe a handful of kisses and pecks total. We have no idea how they will reconcile and, with two more seasons to go (at least), they will almost have to form a Bonnie and Clyde partnership to make it work.

Gus, the DEA, and Not Shitting Where You Eat (But Tipping Graciously)

When Gus Frings (actor Giancarlo Esposito) shows up for a tour of the DEA’s offices in “ABQ,” complete with an “insider” peptalk with Hank, the body bags might as well have flashed on screen like a subliminal message: Skyler and Walt Jr. dead on their lawn. Gus places cash in Walt’s donation jar and eerily chums it up with his brother-in-law. It’s a false alarm of course, albeit a chilling one, because Gus is far too careful to order such an explosion of violence on a public level. That said, at this point, we still don’t know enough about this character to gauge whether he’d ever kill an innocent woman and a teenager. Gilligan offers us a further glimpse into Gus’s mindset in an interview with TV critic Alan Sepinwall: “[Gus] would never have gotten into business with Walt in the first place without doing due diligence: ‘Oh, he’s a high school chemistry teacher, he has a brother-in-law in the DEA,’ etc. In my mind, Gus would be less than he is if he was to be surprised by that.” So, Gus already knew about Walt’s cancer and his familial ties to the authorities. But does Walt know he knows?

Jane’s Father, His Job, Jane’s Death, Hidden Title Codes, and a “Disaster” in the Sky

Jane’s father pulls up to her and Jesse’s apartment complex and through his windshield sees paramedics rolling out an empty stretcher. The general viewer readies for a loud and heartbreaking reaction. But John de Lancie plays it realistically and against expectation. He enters the apartment, stares down at his dead daughter on Jesse’s bed, and walks through police protocol and out the front door as if it were a dream he’s walked through a thousand times. Given his air of defeat and sleepless nights, he no doubt has. However, even Jesse, in his current goner-state, seems perplexed by Donald’s calmness. They don’t speak and barely acknowledge one another. And in a way, Jesse’s loss seems trivial, overly romanticized and magnified by drug abuse, in a room with Jane’s father.

After Donald returns to work a co-worker awkwardly offers his by-the-number condolences in the office kitchen. Donald still has that mile-long stare of sadness. Of course, we find out soon thereafter that Donald is employed as an air-traffic controller. Uh oh. “ABQ” is the abbreviation for Albuquerque Airport. In fact, if you chronogically combine the titles of certain episodes this season you get: “Seven Thirty-Seven” “Down” “Over” “ABQ.”

I’m not sure what the procedure is for returning to Donald’s specific job after a loss in the family et al, but I found it too hard to believe that he would go completely unsupervised. The responsibilities are far too great. I’ve taken similar leaps with Breaking Bad before—like when Walt “suddenly” popped up alongside Hank’s vehicle while he was staking-out Heisenberg—but not this time.

We see the planes moving closer circa ’80s tech-dramas, surrounded in red warning circles, on Donald’s computer screen. Walt is indirectly the source of this disaster, the cause of the deaths of an untold number of innocent people. In my opinion, this is just a really poor, outlandish and cartoonish Faustian example of global (and karmic) connectedness; how our worst decisions and actions come back to bite us. Earlier in the ep, Hank points to a map showing Heisenberg’s meth spreading like wild fire in surrounding states. New Mexico is now curiously short of “The Blue Stuff.” With Gus’s distribution, Walt is creating an entire mid-west of high-grade junkies. The “hotness” on Hank’s map is moving slowly outward, but it’s even more deadly than the red circles in front of Donald’s shifting eyes. The message and theme of connectedness was already being executed perfectly without an exclamation point that conjures religion, god, “cosmic indictment,” fate and 9/11.

The ending also makes all of the teasing throughout the season kind of pointless. Fans are rewarded with a complete psych-out. Even though the pink teddy bear appeared in “Phoenix,” Gilligan says it’s, “Just a little Easter Egg for the people who notice things on that level.” He goes on to compare the bear’s appearence in “Phoenix” to Where’s Waldo. If Gilligan is looking for disappointed and semi-angry fans after his finale’s conclusion, I don’t think he’ll need to squint to find at least a few. Moreover, if Gilligan is headed in an inherently religious direction with Breaking Bad, perhaps he should have countered David Chase’s infamous cut-to-black with a cut-to-blinding-light.

Breaking Bad airs Sundays at 10 p.m. ET/PT on AMC.

Hunter Stephenson can be reached at h.attila[at]gmail.com and on Twitter.

About the Author

  • anyone know where I can watch the first season of this.
  • Mr. 62
    check out ninjavideo.net
  • I agree it was a disappointing season finale, however I don't feel it was as heavy handed, nor as overtly religious as you seem to feel, Hunter.

    As for the scene with Jesse and Walt in the drug den, it was the first time I've teared up watching a TV show this year - maybe I'm a sucker for a bit of melodrama, but the "I loved her more than any...thing" did it for me, haha ;)
  • I agree. It was disappointing in that it wasn't on par with most every other episode in terms of greatness. However, this does not mean, by any stretch, that this was a bad episode. It's still better than most television.

    The drug den scene was very well done, I thought. Perhaps a bit heavy-handed in terms of establishing where they were - showing the "victims" of drug problems a bit more than it needed to. We get it, Walt has played a part in developing this dark world. However, the guy with the face tattoo was very haunting. For just a moment I forgot I was watching a television show and felt a strong sense of fear. The cinematography there was brilliantly executed.

    I can agree that perhaps it was a bit far fetched that Jane's father's work was not more closely supervised, but I disagree with accusations of it becoming 'overtly religious.' The events of this episode were cause-and-effect... so it tip-toed and somewhat crossed a line of realism within the show, that didn't really bother me. In terms of story, it made sense.
  • Not at all disappointing. "747 Down Over ABQ". He was telling us this was what was going to go down from the beginning. This is what had to happen. Everything was leading to this.
    Can you imagine how good next season is going to be? Walt just made it rain fire! What comes next can only be worse.
  • The only thing that bugged me was that he wasn't supervised after coming back to work from a family tragedy, seems like that would be normal procedure.
  • MisterCurtis
    Wow, you really saw more into it I did. I'm not sold on the religious undertones idea. Again it is to be interpreted by the viewer.

    Overall: Great season. Weak finish.
  • I didn't read this because I haven't been able to watch the 2nd season...but god damn I loved the first season of the show. I hope this 2nd season lives up to the first!
  • Wow, great write-up Hunter, mad props yo! ;P

    ** Warning: this comment contains spoilers. **

    I'm also disappointed with the finale. They teased viewers into expecting a grand, wowing climax and instead delivered a crummy, suspense of disbelief breaking “you have been bad Walt, now you're gonna pay 747 dropping out of the sky style, mwhahaha!” cop-out ending.

    I really hope the next season doesn't snowball into a mediocre mess, because aside from the finale and the mindbogglingly uncharacteristic way in which Walt leaves Jane to die, Breaking Bad has been one of the best television shows ever!
  • jason B
    @ hunter

    you get my email about how you have added yet ANOTHER show to my already insane list of must watch tv?!?! i have to say, that the second to last episode, with the conversation about water on mars, was my season 2 2nd favorite moment...my 1st: seeing just how much walt cares about jessie when he calls him his nephew, and goes back to the house to help. (yes, walt white has a fucked up way of helping, but i wouldn't have it any other way)

    imho; breaking bad is the only heir to the sopranos that we have on television. tony soprano may physically mop the floor with walt, but mr. white would outthink any goomba we've ever seen on that show.

    i'm bummed you didn't like the finale, and i found jessie's descent to ring very true - and far from contrived. either way, this is fucking amazing television, again, thanks for the recomendatiion.
  • Chairmanfonz
    "An undetermined amount of time has passed since Walt’s surgery (he now has an unfetching fuzz on his chin)."

    It was about 7 weeks. The doctor asks when he's gonna see the baby and how old it is and Skylar said Holly was about 7 weeks old. Minor issue. Otherwise really good article.
  • well it's actually been more like 11 weeks. Walt's surgery was planned for 4 weeks after the initial meeting with the doctor and 2 weeks after the c-section planned for Holly. but the kid came early.

    i found the scene with him showing his daughter the money he had stashed in the garage particularly touching. it reminded me of the handy cam confession of the very first episode. it's like it came full circle then. and also the way how the money would be laundered as donations through Jr.'s site. ingenious.

    but i do agree that the plane crash was over the top and not needed. even though you probably could've figured that out from the beginning of the season though. US feds don't show up with white suits for murder or arson. here in The Netherlands they do.
  • Verm
    You really should not focus on finding the religious undertones, thats something that should be subtly noticed. It being too blunt is only because you have become too aware of it, and have been interpreting everything around that
  • The
    I was confused by the article as well. Religious undertones (or overtones)?? More like ironic twist of fates using clever plot devices. There wasn't some not-so-subtle christain imagery lieing around (like the airplane exploding in the shape of a cross, etc.) so I have no idea why anybody would immediately latch on to this idea.

    If anything, this WTF? moment was, while completely off-the-wall...and suprisingly perfectly fine by me. To me, this show is the anti-Lost... Breaking Bad started with an absolute goal and predictable plan in mind (walt cooks meth... walt loses wife.. walt jr. does meth... walt realizes pain he's caused... walt dies) and as the show has gone on, completely throws out the rule book and starts throwing shit everywhere, and it's all because some Chemistry teacher at a high school got a pissy mid-life-death-crisis. It's television gold and I can't wait to see just how the show manages to handle all of it.
  • For what it's worth, regarding the bear:

    The bear was either on the mural, or on a shelf, in Jane's room (in her apartment, NOT Jesse's) as her father was surveying it

    Because of that, I thought for sure that Jane was one of the two in the body bags.

    I'm actually one of the few that really enjoyed this episode, but I also heartily agree that the plane collision was a significant letdown. Great summary!
  • edc2
    "it’s a bleak and ridiculous “cosmic” twist on par with a doctor—distraught over a dead daughter caught in mob crossfire—accidentally replacing Tony Soprano’s heart with an ape’s"

    this is the stupidest thing I've read all year. congrats! no go do something better suited to your writing talents, like birthday cards.
  • Bull
    Yeah, that is a terrible "analogy" - if you can call it that.
  • thelastknowngod
    i didnt think this episode was that bad. yes, it was a lot weaker than the rest of the season but i believe it was necessary. they needed to wrap up some of the plot lines of the second season and stear the show in the right direction. its not the best but they had to do it. it will all pay off in season 3.
  • faithless
    I thought the season finale was weak at first, but the more I think about it, its genius. All this season Walt hasn't thought once about the consequences of his actions. Now because of him two planes went down. If he would have saved Jane, her father would not have screwed up. I think the planes were also a metaphor for Walt,"the sky is falling around him."
  • Faraday
    Really, I think you're overthinking the religious aspect of it. There's definitely some symbolism involved, but the point of the episode is hardly taking the show in a religious direction. The whole series has been about the effects of Walt's actions. Until this episode, he's had control over them. Everything that he's done, he's been able to "fix" somehow, or smooth over in some way. Even the death of one of his dealers didn't affect him, nor did Badger going to jail.

    The point of the finale, as I saw it, is that Walt's world is blowing up around him. He's lost all control. His meth is spreading like wildfire thanks to Gus (which means the DEA will be back on Heisenberg's trail), he's lost his wife's trust, he's about to lose his son's respect, and his only friend (Jesse) is a complete mess. All because of Walt. We're going to start seeing some changes and maturation in his character, most likely in the form of regret and attempted salvation for what he's done.

    I think the plane crash was poorly executed, but I believe it existed more as a plot device than a Lucifer Ex Machina. Donald's world is falling apart too. His daughter died and he just killed two plane's worth of people. What if he were to "Break Bad", maybe as someone who's going to try to take revenge on Jesse (and by extension, Walt) for what he's done to his life.

    We've got two seasons left of this show, and how "good" the finale was depends on where they go from here, not how disappointed you were that it didn't live up to your expectations.
  • Ben
    The only thing I'm worried about is that Gilligan said it was God raning down wrath.
    It's just cause and effect, I don't believe there is any real religious undertones. It's just showing what happens because of Walts actions. It isn't any form of punishment on Walts behalf, punishment would be him being found out and locked up in the ol slammer!
  • Slighty dissapointed with the ending, but i feel like next season the consequenses of Walt's and Jesse's actions will become even more pronounced. It was hard to top "Phoenix" from the week before which was one of the darkest and best episodes of television ive ever seen.
  • Darksmile
    To me, the whole plane crash ain't Walt fault. Of course Walt could saved Jane...
    The planes crash was Jane's father fault, a lot of ppl lose some friends, family during their life but they have their obligation/duties, his fault was to go to his job even tho he wasnt able to work, hes the one who caused the planes crash.

    Walt is responsible of Jeese downfall. He never supported jesse, always been rude to him, he's the one using jesse to get what he wants, and look what jesse been thru since he met Walt. Walt never paid attention to that, never helped Jesse. Walt onlty cared about himself with his cancer and family issues. But Jesse's the one suffering for Walt "happiness".

    Beyond the whole religious thing, that's the most important thing which came into my mind during watching this second season.
  • Better late than never I guess, right Hunter...

    Anyway,

    I thought the episode was brilliant in the way that at first you feel a tinge of dissapointment, but then, you look back and you realize that the entire season was setting this up. The entire season and NOBODY guessed what was going to happen. Even the titles of the episodes with the Bear in them spell out EXACTLY what happens "747 Down Over ABQ". Amazing. Brilliant. I can't say enough.
  • @Faraday

    As far as me "overthinking" the religious undertones and overt imagery, keep in mind that it was the series' creator, Vince Gilligan, who used the phrases, "Lucifer ex machina" and "a COSMIC indictment" of Walt's actions this seasons. Not me. Like I said in the article, I definitely considered that I had misinterpreted the imagery from the standpoint of a viewer who is not religious at all. But then I read Gilligan's comments on numerous sites, including the Q&A with viewers on Breaking Bad's site. I disagree that I am "seeing too much into it," considering that I waited to see Gilligan's candid take on the finale.

    @Verm

    It's quite difficult to "not focus on the religious undertones, that's something that should be subtly noticed," when the major "undertone" in "ABQ" is an event in which two airliners collide directly above the main character's head and rain down upon him, per the words of Vince Gilligan, as "the wrath of God."

    @steveo22

    Nice comment. I agree that Breaking Bad is about "cause-and-effect"---it mirrors the series' and Walt's interest in chemistry---but the finale's collision exists far outside this theme. Not only was the collision the most grandiose event/consequence experienced by Walt, but the odds of this happening seemed tipped by a higher authority. Gilligan has agreed that it was even the act of a "vengeful God." Take a look at some of the links provided in the article. I think you'll be surprised by how candid he's being about the finale's end-meaning. That said, even if he didn't provide these explanations, allusions to the Bible and "End Times" in this scene were obvious to me. Even to the point where Walt is "left behind" by his family due to his prior actions. And then fire falls all around him. It would be a tad different if the collision happened far away. But this was a giant whiffff for the show, though the series remains one of my favorites.

    @Chuck

    You are right. The pink teddy bear was also seen in the mural Jane painted on her wall. If the teddy bear is simply an "Easter egg" as Gilligan has stated, why make fans work that hard? While the bear represents nothing in of itself, placing it physically in the series without a logical explanation was a terrible creative decision. It feels like a loose-end that the writers couldn't figure out themselves. A cop-out.

    Nice comments so far. I know the opinions expressed are bolder than in previous write-ups, but that's a reaction to a finale episode that simply doesn't fit with what's come before.

    @ steveo22
  • Drew
    I've got one word to describe these so-called "heavy-handed religious overtones" that somehow soiled this finale: METAPHOR. I highly, highly, HIGHLY doubt Vince Gilligan is really suggesting that some sort of Satanic force has a central influence on this story -- Satan is NOT a character on this show. What Hunter failed to do was include the part of the quote where Gilligan said "In my mind" -- thereby taking it out of context to better suit your argument (intentionally or not, that's what you did). The fact of the matter is, Walt has caused a lot of problems for himself and others, and his actions are now beginning to spread to people whom he does not directly know (Jane's father, the people on the plane, etc.) This is ART, and people who create art like to use SYMBOLISM. Again -- God, or Satan, or Buddha, or whoever else was not the one who caused those planes to crash -- it was Walt's moral dilemma. I found this finale to be imperfect, yes, but I found the ending (deus ex machina and all) to be both compelling and tasteful.

    One more thing -- anyone else notice that the bear was meant to represent Walt? Pink bear, scruffy fur -- Walt wearing pink shirt when the planes collide, scruffy facial hair? The bear wasn't irrelevant -- it was symbolic all along.

    Come on people, this isn't that hard.
  • I like what you said about the bear. I haven't heard anything from Gilligan about it but Hunter said that it's just an easter egg for the viewers who notice things like that. I say that if it is Walt, I guess that means he's fallen from the good graces of God, or his family, or the community, and now has to hit rock bottom before being saved and being able to return to the good graces of everyone around him.
  • @Drew

    Per the teddy bear, it doesn't make any sense within the realistic world that Gilligan has established for a stuffed animal to appear at the drug transaction in "Phoenix" and then for it to suddenly fall out of the sky in "ABQ" into Walt's pool. I would have no problem if the bear wasn't shown in "Phoenix," thus making it a harmless sight-gag as Gilligan proclaims. There is no logical explanation for the bear going from point A to point B, unless we come to find in Season Three that one of Gus's people, or someone in the vicinity of the transaction, was on one of the planes. The focus on the bear all season long combined with its ultimately random, inexplicable appearance in the finale was disappointing.

    As for a scorched teddy bear symbolizing Walt's decline, okay. But what is the deeper message behind it beyond a connection of color? There isn''t one. So, why praise the bear as superlative "symbolism" to justify the finale's bogus ending?
  • Paul
    Here's a guess, the bear was in Phoenix as a mistake. Gilligan didn't cop to it, who likes to admit mistakes?

    Besides, we can be sure that the bear at the drug deal and the bear that fell out of the plane were not the same bear.

    Truthfully, showing the aftermath for Don wasn't a bad decision in my opinion, but the ending didn't quite gel.

    I do get that the bear that fell from the plane is connected to the one in Jane's mural, but it still didn't work for me. (I have no problem with magical realism, but it's very tricky to use.)
  • Drew
    Oh, and I really like Faraday's comment: "We've got two seasons left of this show, and how "good" the finale was depends on where they go from here, not how disappointed you were that it didn't live up to your expectations."

    So true.
  • Joe
    Like a lot of other people, my gut reaction to the Season 2 finale was one of disappointment. However, it wasn't the supposed religious undertones that bothered me, but rather the extraordinarily high level of coincidence necessary for everything to transpire in the way it did. The Gilligan interview did indeed use the terms "cosmic indictment" and "Lucifer ex machina," but I got the impression that he was mostly referencing the latter as a flip side of "deus ex machina" as a storytelling device. For me, the term "deus ex machina" always conjures up bad memories of the ending of Snake Eyes - which, if I recall correctly, had no religious overtones - and is predominantly a lazy, cop-out device to help tie up loose ends. It's similar to those scenes in action movies where the hero is hopelessly outnumbered by his foes, but then ... wait ... his buddy/sidekick/woman/other ancillary character comes to his rescue with a shitload of help he/she conveniently gathered. Part of the enjoyment I derive from seeing a story unfold is in being surprised and dazzled by how smoothly and unexpectedly the pieces all come together. A typical "deus ex machina" robs you of that, opting instead to let the narrative threads hit a wall instead of beautifully dovetailing into a thematically resonant, creative ending.
  • Joe
    This is why some people will always hate Magnolia and now the Season 2 finale of Breaking Bad. At first glance, their endings leave you scratching your head and feeling cheated. But I would argue that both provide examples of atypically satisfying deus ex machina endings that are in fact subtly set up and thematically appropriate. In terms of message, tone, content, etc, Magnolia is far different from Breaking Bad, but both heavily underscore the role of coincidence in the narrative. Since the first season, Breaking Bad has striven to show how connected its characters are, whether they know it or not. The first time my antennae went up on that was when Hank took Walt Jr. to see the meth skank (not Spooge's Skank) at the motel, who then proceeded to enter a hotel room where Jesse was waiting. Obviously this was nowhere near as far-fetched or extreme a coincidence as the closing events of Season 2 (and, at that point, they didn't exactly know where they were headed with subsequent seasons) - especially since we've seen those two together before - but it was a moment that took the time to establish how even the most disparate lives intersect. Little moments like this abound, even in the first season - the asshole student showing up at the car wash, Walt revealing he bought furniture from Krazy-8's family's store, the re-encountering of Ken Wins, even the circumstances leading to Walt's involvement with Jesse in the first place - and while not all are necessarily coincidences, they illustrate the unpredictable ways in which we all cross each other's paths and don't even know it.
  • Joe
    From the beginning, the show has incorporated chemistry into the narrative in wonderfully innovative ways (though it admittedly got heavy-handed at times). It's a brilliant way to reinforce cause-and-effect themes in a show as morally conscious as Breaking Bad, and in most cases, the events that result from actions all make some sort of rational sense. Like chemical reactions, the consequences to previous actions were explosive and unpredictable, but fairly cut-and-dried. Walt plans to let Krazy-8 go, but then must kill him. The Spooge incident is bad and potentially incriminating, but Walt and Jesse milk it for intimidation purposes. And so on and so forth.

    But the moment Donald and Walt ran into each other in that bar, all that was out the window. A random, heartfelt conversation between two strangers leads to a horrible moment of inaction, which slowly, inexorably spirals into a flat-out fucking catastrophe. It all makes perfect sense to us, the omniscient viewers, but to the characters within the Breaking Bad world, it's a completely random freak accident (at this point at least - who knows if Walt or any of the other characters will connect the dots). That's how life is, and if there is a God or some such all-knowing entity, He/it would be able to discern how and to what extent we are connected. Coincidences are created by coincidences, and in the case of Breaking Bad, it's really one gigantic coincidence that sets up a domino effect of coincidences/consequences. The knee-jerk reaction to this is "Oh, what the fuck?" but once I thought about it, I found it to be thoughtful and ballsy. That being said, if they do end up spinning this into some full-blown religious allegory, I'll be more disappointed than anybody. I doubt a show that gleans dark humor out of the cleanup of slushy, acid-dissolved human remains is too concerned about convincing us to go to church.
  • Joe
    I so strongly disagree with the bear tease being a terrible creative decision. In retrospect, it's a rather hilarious red herring (it would have been funny but way too obvious if it was a stuffed, actual red herring). I love how Gilligan leads us to believe that Walt will lose his family through nasty but localized bloodshed, but then he ends up non-violently losing them AND indirectly killing a ridiculous amount of innocent people.

    I would concede that the finale is a letdown in comparison to Phoenix, which is one of the best episodes of a TV show I've ever seen. But before the actual plane crash (which, to be fair, is a bit cheesily executed), I think the episode is on par with the others this season.

    Also, though this doesn't entirely erase the implausibility of Donald being allowed back to work so soon after his daughter's death, Donald did mention a lack of manpower to Jane during one of their conversations. I'm not sure what exactly he said, but it was something to do with more pressure at work coming from having to train a bunch of new people. This was never alluded to at the air traffic center, but maybe that played into the decision to let him return to work that quickly.

    Either way, I think Breaking Bad will continue to kick infinitely more ass than anything else on TV. It's going to be a long, long time til March.
  • Despite the lame ending, there is still pleanty to work with for next season. I'm still excited.
  • Greg
    Religious overtones? Come on, you're reading too much into this. And if I was going to read too much into your review of the season finale, I'd say that you had religious parents who locked you in a closet when you were a kid. What was with that axe you were grinding in that review?
  • darksmile
    And ITS STILL THE BEST SHOW ON TV NOWADAYS
  • Daniel
    I think you should to re-read that interview. Vince clearly states that this is all Walts doing.

    "In simple terms, we just wanted a giant moment of showmanship to end the season. And what better way than to have a rain of fire coming down around our protagnoist's ears, sort of like the judgment of God?"

    he says LIKE the judgement of god. He never states that god had anything to do with it. He also says:

    "In that moment, at the end of season two, he doesn't realize it, but he's responsible for the whole world figuratively coming to an end around him."

    It sounds to me like Vince clearly intended that God has nothing to do with it and everything that happend is because of Walt.
  • You know I haven't been a big fan of this series, but I watched casually this season and all of the finale. And I've just got one thing to say with anyone who was disappointed with the finale---Are you PEOPLE OUT OF YOUR MINDS? That was brilliant! Sheer fucking brilliance. Ranks right up there with the Fringe finale and just a little below the Lost one. I just watched seasons one and two all the way through this week and now consider myself a fan of this show. It's not about God or Satan. That's bullshit. Lucifier ex machina--Good God who the fuck came up with that shit. Walt made the meth that caused this shit to happen. He's responsible. Everything else is blatant metaphor or karmic retribution.
  • ConcreteLogic
    How heavy handed could it be if you are the only person I have seen make the connection? Even after reading your article I am baffled at how you came to the religious connections.
  • This is a great show and I was a little bummed out about the finale but I am happy no one important died. I never saw this coming and now that I look back at the titles of the episodes, it was very possible to figure out what was going to happen. I guess I really don't look into the show as deeply as others but I think I'll start to change that with season 3. I have no idea what's going to happen since the last few seconds of the show leave everything wide open.
  • James
    It's just a dream he's having while in surgery. Some of it is real some of it isn't. It became very fragmented right when he feel asleep in surgery. The bright pink shirt didn't feel "real"

    Anyways, that's what I tell myself after being disappointed by the finale.
  • @Faraday

    As far as me "overthinking" the religious undertones and overt imagery, keep in mind that it was the series' creator, Vince Gilligan, who used the phrases, "Lucifer ex machina" and "a COSMIC indictment" of Walt's actions this season. Not me. Like I said in the article, I definitely considered that I had misinterpreted the imagery from the standpoint of a viewer who is not religious at all. But then I read Gilligan's comments on numerous sites, including the Q&A with viewers on Breaking Bad's site. I disagree that I am "seeing too much into it," considering that I waited to see Gilligan's candid take on the finale.

    @Verm

    It's quite difficult to "not focus on the religious undertones, that's something that should be subtly noticed," when the major "undertone" in "ABQ" is an event in which two airliners collide directly above the main character's head and rain down upon him, per the words of Vince Gilligan, as "the wrath of God."

    @steveo22

    Nice comment. I agree that Breaking Bad is about "cause-and-effect"---it mirrors the series' and Walt's interest in chemistry---but the finale's collision exists far outside this theme. Not only was the collision the most grandiose event/consequence experienced by Walt, but the odds of this happening seemed tipped by a higher authority. Gilligan has agreed that it was even the act of a "vengeful God." Take a look at some of the links provided in the article. I think you'll be surprised by how candid he's being about the finale's end-meaning. That said, even if he didn't provide these explanations, allusions to the Bible and "End Times" in this scene were obvious to me. Even to the point where Walt is "left behind" by his family due to his prior actions. And then fire falls all around him. It would be a tad different if the collision happened far away. But this was a giant whiffff for the show (though the series remains one of my favorites).

    @Chuck

    You are right. The pink teddy bear was also seen in the mural Jane painted on her wall. If the teddy bear is simply an "Easter egg" as Gilligan has stated, why make fans work that hard? While the bear represents nothing in of itself, placing it physically in the series without a logical explanation was a terrible creative decision. It play like a loose-end that the writers couldn't figure out themselves. A cop-out.

    Nice comments so far. I know the opinions expressed are bolder than in previous write-ups, but that's a reaction to a finale episode that simply doesn't fit with what's come before.
  • Jacob
    I agree with Daniel, the original interview states quite the opposite of what this article says, Its all about chaos theory, everything Walt does has effected the world and lives around him, including the people on those planes. not GOD. The people around him, his family, his dealers, his friend, everyone is getting hurt because of his decisions.

    As for the author of this review, it's obvious that you are quite the anti-religious person, and that's fine. but just this one time, could you have a little faith?
  • The
    ^This.

    Stop trying to make this show about religion and re-watch the finale (and just WATCH the finale.. don't try pointing at crosses the entire time).

    When creators of shows spout words like dues ex machina... they usually aren't speaking about God (because, THEY ARE GOD in relation to the show), they are speaking about plot devices and twists, etc. Walt just experienced karma... not God.
  • Fourthman
    A poster over on the Onoin's AV Club summed up the cause of the disappointment many of us BB fans feel: "It's all a little too neat, but that's part of the appeal of fiction: you can make a world with order and create poetic justice instead of relying on random chance to make something half-interesting." Yes, I get the metaphor, but I don't appreciate the departure from the throughline of the story in order to get there. Also, the pink teddy bear in 'Phoenix', according to Gilligan, is a reward? I thought rewards paid off.

    Great show, mediocre season finale.
  • hunter, i really enjoy these writeups you've been doing.

    i was also totally disappointed by the ending. like you pointed out, its almost as if the ending was supposed to disappoint. i don't see any other reason to hype something so dramatic to the plot, and then essentially dismiss any logical outcome with a bogus event that will hardly effect the show. its one thing to have a twist, but its another to pull some bullshit like this in the last 30 seconds. i think the explanation or justification of the plane crash is halfass, being an 'act of god', or walt's actions indirectly effecting others. i get it, but it's not very interesting. thats something i would expect to see on a show like lost, because it is retarded. this show has always been generally believable, and this just didnt work. i think it would have played off alright if they never created such anticipation for the ending.. if they never had the previews of the destruction at walt's house.. if they just had the plane crash, it would still have been a bit much, but it would be ok... i just cant understand why they purposely set out to disappoint the viewer. sure its a 'twist' nobody was expecting, but it didn't make the show better at all.
  • Lenny Yo
    Plane crash over the top. Wouldn't the RADAR alarm when the two planes got too close or some other type of electronic warning?

    Skylar is tremendous acting. Walt Jr. needs to get his slur consistent. Sometimes he slurs more than others. Is that normal for CP or his lack of consistency?

    Saul is freakin' hilarious. Love him.

    I had a bad picture on a laptop. Gus seemed very mild mannered with mild skin tone when was the chicken owner. His face seemed to get a lot more sinister color when he revealed he was a drug lord. Was this just my imagination?
  • anuscakes
    I feel it's more how things tie together universally and we are never aware. Not necessarily a force intervening. Kinda cool. I felt in no way Walt was being punished religious undertones or not. However others paid for what he did.
  • Cheeseman
    Well, call me whatever you want, but I LOVED the grand finale. It blew me out of the water, which at a technical standpoint, was the exact opposite of what we saw.

    Don't get me wrong, the plane crash was unnecessary, but I'm glad they put it in there. If I were in charge of the show, I would've shown one scene of the crash, and go straight to the teddy bear cannonballing into Walt's pool, but remember, hence on the word IF.

    As for what the crash symbolized, God and Satan didnot cross my mind. To me, it only stood for one thing.

    "YOU ARE FUCKED, WALT!"
blog comments powered by Disqus