Over the weekend I went and saw Race to Witch Mountain, mostly due to the fact that, as a kid, I was a fan of the original 1975 film. Also, I’ve always found Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson amusing, even despite some of the really crappy movies he’s done over the years. I was expecting a fun kiddie flick, and nothing more… but I didn’t even get that.

I’m not saying that Escape to Witch Mountain was a masterpiece, or even a good film for that matter. I’m sure if I had revisited that film over the weekend, I might have been largely disappointed over the extreme difference between my memories and reality.

On a sidenote of a sidenote, I recently had a conversation with Dan Trachtenberg of the Totally Rad Show about a theory I like to call “Retro Pop Culture Smell”. You know how when you buy new things, and they have this “new purchase smell”? Apple products are a great example of this. Well “Retro Pop Culture Smell” is like that but the complete opposite.

There are movies that you watched as a child, or at a particular moment in your life, that will never be as good as when you watched them. But that initial experience of watching the film blends into your memory of the film itself, and when you revisit that film, those experiences can sometime cloud your ability to see the film for what it actually is. Anyway, moving on…

My point is that even if I rewatched the original film, I’m not sure I could evaluate it on the same level of someone who had never seen it before. But I’m pretty sure the original film was at least 73 times more magical and wonderful than the remake. Screenplay, acting, and special effects aside, I was really surprised to discover how badly directed some of the action sequences were in the film.  Andy Flickman had even been rumored to helm a Johnny Quest movie adaptation. But as we all know, being a good director isn’t important as long as you can turn out whatever the studio wants, under budget, and the resulting film makes a profit. Hey, it is the movie BUSINESS after all.

And following the opening weekend of Witch Mountain, Disney has announced that Flickman will helm a big screen adaptation of Marc Bernardin and Adam Freeman’s graphic novel, Monster Attack Network. And since MAT is being produced at Dinsey, and Flickman’s last two Disney family films starred The Rock, I wouldn’t be surprised if we see the duo reunite for this film as well. The official plot synopsis of the comic book follows:

“MARVEL! At the Pacific island of Lapuatu, perfect in every way…except for the giant monsters. THRILL! As Nate Klinger and his daring team of first-responders at the Monster Attack Network expertly deal with the frequent rampaging-beast-related crises. WONDER! If the shady American industrialist who comes to the island bearing “gifts” and the mysterious, gorgeous Lapuatuan ex-patriate are up to no good. ENJOY! The hair-raising adventures of the noble men and the drop-dead sexy women of the MONSTER ATTACK NETWORK!”

Scott Elder and Josh Harmon have been hired to script the adaptation. Monsters vs. Aliens, the next computer animated film from Dreamworks also involves big city-attacking monsters, but in a twist, they join forces with the U.S. Government to protect the planet against alien invaders.

  • Nice theory peter. I'm sure we'll all be referencing it from now on out here.
  • gah
    it won't be hard to put it into practice since a new remake is announced daily.
  • I just wonder, which film is not being remaked?
  • Soylent Green. Great as it is it is very dated and could use one.
  • Josh
    Now that you just said that, some executive is about to pitch a Soylent Green remake.
  • true, but a lot of the stuff they are remaking i didn't even grow up with.
  • The Rock says....
    How dare you come into the People's Blog, and run your mouth about how The Great One's movie sucks. I'll tell you what The Rock is gonna do, The Rock is gonna grab an electrifying copy of his movie "Doom", shine it up real nice, turn that sum'bitch sideways, and stick it straight up your CANDY ASS!
  • I thought i could smell what you were cooking...
  • freemachine
    ...and you were cooking it down on Jabroni Street!
  • You made me so happy with this post. Reminded me of The Rock when he was turned into a scorpion :)
  • starscream9289
    Because FINALLY, The Rock has come back to SLASHFILM.COM!
  • Frankly I could enjoy that. Go back and watch it, it is screaming to be remade.
  • freemachine
    I'm not a fan of remakes, but Soylent Green is one that could be updated. Imagine an economic crisis, as we are in now, with a food shortage, which is already occurring in some places. Recall how rice was being rationed last year and impossible for some third world countries to obtain? This could easily be parlayed into a decent dystopian-future script.
  • After seeing "Watchmen" I walked into "Witch Mountain" during the scene when the kids go into the house and to the basement being chased by a robot. The set looked like a third rate amusement park, with fake plants and faker boulders all over the place. All my girlfriend and I could take was about minutes of The Rock's eyebrow acting before we left. It wasn't even worth it for free.
  • If they make this movie in the same way they made the old monster filcks I'll go see it, from the sound of the description that's what they are gonna try but I think it would be quite bold of disney to make a purposely cheap (but expensive) movie. I hold out hope though for an actually funny movie.
  • MrBabyMan
    Totally agree. As nostalgic as I am over the original Escape to Witch Mountain, if you revisit it today, you'd find it tepid and a little cheap. Remember, these were low-budget films the Disney Studios were churning out at the time, and overall Disney's sensibility of "hip" was about ten years behind the times. I've seen Tron recently, and it too definitely has Retro Pop Culture Smell all over it. I just hope nobody waxes nostalgic over 'The Cat From Outer Space' or 'Unidentified Flying Oddball' enough to want to remake them.
    Incidentally, the sequel to the original film, Return From Witch Mountain (1978), besides featuring weak performances from Bette Davis and Christopher Lee, has a pretty kickass 'force throw' battle between Tony and Tia that I'm fairly positive George Lucas ripped off for 'The Empire Strikes Back' two years later.
  • PintelGuy
    I'm sure Disney will keep lines like: "How many times have I told you about that 'sir' bullshit?" and "Damn right," intact.
    Also, since when was Monster Attack Network abbreviated to MAT?!
  • yeah, I feel you on that Retro Pop Theory, Peter, fuck remakes. They just imitate the originals, but have no soul of their own.
  • I barely turned 20, and I completely understand Peter.
    Like hearing the Superman score and then the credits start rolling for the first time and being convinced that Christopher Reeves WAS Superman. It just wasn't really the same when I watched Superman Returns, and not that I hated the movie. Things on that same parallel do not need to be done over.
blog comments powered by Disqus