jason butler harner changeling

The Academy Awards for 2008 have been handed out, and the “popular kids” have Oscars on their mantles, but the dirty little secret about winning awards is that you’ve gotta campaign for them. Thousands of dollars were spent by the distributors and filmmakers behind Slumdog Millionaire (Fox Searchlight), Milk (Focus Features), The Reader (Weinstein) and other assorted winners and nominees, but not all performances received that sort of big money backing.

I am an unabashed lover of the acting craft. I see virtually every movie, large and small, that passes through the US marketplace, and, taking nothing away from Sean Penn, Kate Winslet, Penelope Cruz and Heath Ledger, not all of 2008’s best performances have been recognized. I’m not going to be obvious here. Clint Eastwood was snubbed for Gran Torino, but he received lots of acclaim for the role including being named Best Actor by the National Board of Review. My goal is to highlight 10 performances from last year that have received virtually no acclaim in the US. Many of these roles can be found in hardly-seen, under-appreciated movies that came and went without much notice. Each and every one of these movies deserve a spot in your Netflix (or Blockbuster) cue.

My list is by no means definitive. If you have a favorite performance from 2008 that sticks with you, this is a great place to tell the world. There were 20 actors nominated on Oscar night, but there is a lot of great work that hasn’t been recognized with a walk down the red carpet.

oss 117

1. JEAN DUJARDIN, 0SS 117: CAIRO NEST OF SPIES
This was the funniest movie of the year for me. OSS 117, a reboot of a previously successful franchise, was a hit in France, but generated only about $300,000 in very limited engagements in the US. Dujardin is a James Bond-style secret agent who bumbles his way across the middle east with the panache of Sean Connery and the comic physicality of Peter Sellers. He was nominated for Best Actor at the Cesar Awards (French Oscars), but almost nobody saw Nest of Spies here. The sequel OSS 117: Rio Ne Repond Plus is due later this year. Steve Martin, who badly resurrected the Pink Panther franchise, should watch this movie with a deep sense of shame.

patricia clarkson elergy

2. PATRICIA CLARKSON, ELEGY
Sold about $3.5M in tickets at American box offices. In many ways, Penelope Cruz’s performance here is more courageous and luminous than her winning turn in Vicky Cristina Barcelona, but I am choosing to focus on Patricia Clarkson who brings a heartfelt honest to her small role. I am always impressed when a woman is unafraid to appear nude in a film, especially if it gives us a window into that character’s soul. Clarkson is close to 50 and her character is maintaining a purely sexual relationship with Ben Kingsley’s David Kepesh. She has no illusions about being young or being in love. She is settling for the occasional comfort of a tumble with this man, and sadly, her constant career demands make a permanent loving relationship a faraway idea.

bill irwin rachel getting married

3. BILL IRWIN, RACHEL GETTING MARRIED
Loading a dishwasher has never been so dramatic. Primarily a theatre actor (he played George alongside Kathleen Turner in the 2005 Broadway revival of Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf), he does something very different in Jonathan Demme’s documentary-style Rachel Getting Married. He is the buttoned-down, peacemaker who is hiding a shattered emotional interior that comes forward in a remarkable scene in which he demonstrates how to correctly load a dishwasher. Oscar nominee Anne Hathaway and Golden Globe nominee Rosemarie DeWitt were both excellent, but Irwin’s performance has stayed with me in a meaningful way.

elsa zylberstein ive loved you so long

4. ELSA ZYLBERSTEIN, I’VE LOVED YOU SO LONG
This extraordinary French film from the masterful Phillippe Claudel features the luminescent-but-prickly Kristin Scott Thomas, who was nominated for the Golden Globe for Best Actress - Drama and many other awards. Elsa Zylberstein portrays the fully accepting sister who loves without any strings attached. She unwinds the mystery about why her sister committed a horrible act, and simultaneously remains patient and receptive. She allows for as happy an ending as this film can possible allow. Her soulful beauty softens the rough edges of Kristin Scott Thomas’ Juliette.

chiwetel ejiofor redbelt

5. CHIWETEL EJIOFOR, REDBELT
David Mamet does a movie about Mixed Martial Arts. Go figure. The master of dialogue practices jujitsu in real-life, and now he has found a way to incorporate it into one of his films. Chiwetel Ejiofer portrays Mike Terry whose mantra is that “There is always an escape.” Some Hollywood types, played with the appropriate dollops of sleaze and smarminess by Tim Allen and Joe Mantegna, put him in an impossible situation, and he must find the escape. A buff Ejiofor delivers physically (easy to buy him as a badass), and he has a rigid sense of honor. His scene with Emily Mortimer in which she exorcises a past demon in worth the price of admission.

6. KARINA FERNANDEZ, HAPPY-GO-LUCKY
I love Happy-Go-Lucky. Writer/Director Mike Leigh takes a full year rehearsing and improving with his actors in order to finalize the script. He hit solid gold with Poppy, played by Sally Hawkins, who won the Golden Globe and, I assume, narrowly missed an Oscar nomination for Best Actress. The same can be said for Eddie Marsan as the anal retentive driving instructor Scott. But my shout-out here goes British stage actress Karina Fernandez who, in two short scenes, demonstrates her rigid and unbending love for the flamenco and that those very steps may be the only thing keeping her from becoming emotionally unhinged.

7. HAAZ SLEIMAN, THE VISITOR
So much of the lightness in Oscar nominee Richard Jenkins’ turn in The Visitor is his reaction to the joyful drumming of Haaz Sleiman’s Tarek Khalil character. His co-star Danai Jekesai Gurira is also wonderful, but something tells me that the Lebanese-born Sleiman will be heard from again. After drumming with reckless abandon at one point, Tarek realizes that he is going to be late and says his girlfriend will kill him because he’s on Arab time, “It means I’m late by an hour. All Arabs are late by an hour, It’s genetic. We can’t help it.”

8. CANTINCA UNTARU, THE FALL
The weirdest, most fantastical movie of 2008 was directed by Tarsem Singh, whose best-known previous film was the strikingly visual horror pic The Cell, starring Jennifer Lopez. This is a fable told by an injured, drug-addicted stuntman in the early 20th century who befriends a little girl. Lee Pace (brilliant in the 2003 film Soldier’s Girl and also seen in ABC’s short-lived Pushing Daisies) weaves a spectacular fantasy that plays out in the imagination of a little girl played by novice actor Cantinca Untaru. I love this movie, and I’m not alone. Roger Ebert wrote, “You might want to see this for no other reason than because it exists. There will never be another like it.” Part Wizard of Oz. Part Lord of the Rings. 100% original. And it all works because of the innocence and spontaneity of a chIld actress before the camera for the first time.

9. KATE DEL CASTILLO, UNDER THE SAME MOON
She is absolutely beautiful and has a number of popular telenovelas to her credit including El Derecho De Nacer, Ramona, La Mentira and Imperio De Crystal before mading the jump to American television with the 2002 PBS series American Family from creator Gregory Nava (Selena, Mi Familia). This heartbreaking story of a little Mexican boy who decides to try to make it over the border to find his mother, working as a nanny and sending money home, is sweet and pulls at the heartstrings, and this Patricia Riggen movie also features a strong performance from Mexican comic actor Eugenio Derbez.

10. JASON BUTLER HARNER, CHANGELING
I did not like Changeling. I am a huge fan of Eastwood the director, and, for me, Angelina Jolie’s performance was one-note, Jeffrey Donovan from TV’s Burn Notice was doing a 1930’s rat-ta-ta-tat dialect while Oscar nominee Amy Ryan (Gone Baby Gone) seemed to be playing it present day. As for the art direction, it’s been done so much better in classics like Chinatown and more recent noir like L.A. Confidential. But, the reason to see the movie is Jason Butler Harner as serial killer Gordon Stewart Northcott. He conveys a certain cavalier smarminess when confronted with his evil deeds. He enjoys the infamy he has achieved and uses it to manipulate and torture Jolie’s Christine Collins. Unsettling and unforgettable.

HONORARY MENTIONS
-in no particular order-

MILA KUNIS, FORGETTING SARAH MARSHALL

MISTY UPHAM, FROZEN RIVER

DON CHEADLE, TRAITOR

DAVID KROSS, THE READER

REBECCA MILLER, VICKY CRISTINA BARCELONA

JEFFREY WRIGHT, CADILLAC RECORDS

EVAN RACHEL WOOD, THE WRESTLER

DANNY MCBRIDE, PINEAPPLE EXPRESS

DOMINIQUE PINON, ROMAN DE GARE

TILDA SWINTON, THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON

PAUL RUDD, ROLE MODELS

RICKY GERVAIS, GHOST TOWN

ALAN RICKMAN, BOTTLE SHOCK

  • gah
    Steve, eagerly awaiting your Watchmen B.O. predictions.
  • Quite a few nice surprises on here! Namely personal faves Karina Fernandez, Haaz Sleiman and Cantinca Untaru. Gervais and Rudd both had nice turns in what initially appeared to be some fairly standard fair.

    I'd say the two biggest omissions here would be Lena Leandersson and Kare Hedebrandt, the two child leads in the Swedish film "Let the Right One In." Absolutely mesmerizing stuff.
  • The Wackness came out last year at Sundance so IDK if it counts toward this years, but Ben Kingsley in The Wackness. Also Cate Blanchet got screwed out of a nomination for Ben Button. She's the only one that didn't get a nomination.
  • Matt
    Agreed about Kingsley. Should have gotten an oscar nom.
  • The Wackness was a great movie. Ben is so underated.
  • The Wackness was a great movie.
  • He was great in The Wackness
  • Avi
    Don't forget the little kid in Role Models
  • ROLE_FAN
    Hell to the yes. That movie was freaking awesome.
  • Cantinca was amazing. Though The Fall had its flaws with the acting and script, it's still one of the most visually stunning movies I've ever seen and probably will ever see.
  • i recently finished the Six Feet Under series, and am a big fan of Patricia Clarkson. I will have to check out Elegy
  • Starchild
    Paul Rudd deserved an Oscar for Role Models just for his facial expressions alone. Seriously, the looks on his face were just hysterical.

    If Robert Downey Jr. got nominated for being a white guy playing a black guy, why couldn't Paul Rudd win for playing a white guy who dressed up as the star child from KISS and throws a hissy fit in a Starbucks? Oh, and crash a Minotaur truck into a buffalo so it looks they're getting it on.
  • Yeah it had a shitty narrative but the acting and visuals made the movie really memorable... Great list, though I thought Jason Butler Harner sucked in Changeling... though I think that about most of the cast in Changeling.
  • I'm wondering as much as praise TDK got, no one mentiones Gary Oldman... he was brilliant
  • gah
    Usually a given.
  • He was the best thing about the film, easily.
  • ouch, you really dont like TDK do you?
  • Kevin
    I would go with Hiam Abbass (the mother) before Haaz Sleiman in The Visitor, but that's just me.
  • /ambient
    Steve,
    Great list! I highly agree!!!! Interesting choice with Bill Irwin. He was fantastic in Rachel Getting Married and so good I didn't notice his performance until you mentioned him. Sometimes roles are so good they're transparent to the film's surroundings. Also, I thought the Fall was fantastic too!
  • Tom
    And he's also great as Mr. Noodle on Elmo's World, lol
  • Spartank
    Zero love for Michael Fassbender in Hunger? It was a brilliantly understated performance.
  • Jon
    It's Rebecca Hall in Vicky Christina Barcelona not Rebecca Miller.
  • I'd like to point out that anything that Chiwetel Ejiofor does is amazing. He's just an amazing actor. From his small role in Inside Man to a spectacular villain in Serenity to his underrated villainous role in Four Brothers, he is just one of the better actors out there. Inside Man is one of my favorite movies and he almost steals the spotlight from three of the finest actors of our time in Clive Owen, Denzel Washington, and Jodie Foster and he is barely even in the movie. I love that guy.
  • Palmer
    Strange...I just finished watching Redbelt.
  • Palmer
    Strange...I just finished watching Redbelt, and I do agree!
  • Pat
    YESSSS, Harner is brilliant in Changeling.
  • 8. CANTINCA UNTARU, THE FALL
    Great choice. Watch the making of in the DVD and see how natural this girl was. During the making of the movie Tarsem made her (and the rest of the cast) believe that Lee Pace was actually handicapped, so she reacts to him as if he were truly injured, and her sincerity is one of the reasons why this movie really works.
    Kind of twisted when you think about it, but very effective.
  • Pat
    Oh, and my answer is Sam Rockwell for Snow Angels!
  • Ben Franklin
    Some really great choices on here. I thought Harner was great in Changeling (he made you sympathize with him at time, even knowing what he'd done) and that Cantinca Untaru was equally brilliant in The Fall.
  • Vapor
    Will Smith should have won for Seven Pounds!
  • LOL_FAN
    I totally agree!


    not
  • Simon
    Jeff Goldbloom - Adam Resurrected!!!!!!
  • Overlooked
    Jean Claude Van Damme for J.C.V.D -- a truly career defining performance.
  • agree with you on that. He was excellent in that.
  • Aequitas
    You were spot on with BILL IRWIN, PATRICIA CLARKSON & HAAZ SLEIMAN. I havent seen redbelt yet but i have heard great stuff about it. However, i think you forgot to mention some other really under-rated performances... Namely Michael Fassbender & Liam Cunningham for HUNGER and Benecio Del Toro for Che. Also JCVD was also a preety great performance. Sam Rockwell is never under-rated in my book so snow angel was definitely expected from such a high caliber actor.
  • I'm really glad you mentioned Jean Dujardin as OSS 117 was one of my favorite movies from last year. I've told all my friends to watch it and it recently became available on Netflix watch instantly so now I can watch it again.
  • Colin Farrell deserved a lot more love for "In Bruges" than he got even when you consider his Globe win. A perfect performance in an all around brilliant film that gets better with each viewing. Gleeson and Fiennes were great too.
  • Colin Farrell deserved a lot more love for "In Bruges" than he got, even when you consider his Globe win. A perfect performance in an all around brilliant film that gets better with each viewing. Gleeson and Fiennes were great too.
  • I am glad that this list is out there. People think that what the Academy chooses is the creme of the creme when in actuality it's the movies that had enough buzz or money to catch the interest of the board.
  • the serial killer from THE CHANGELING was definitely creepy and scared the shit out of me, he deserves recognition for his performance.
  • scar
    I'm sorry you fucking morons. WHY THE FUCK DID YOU LEAVE OUT DEL TORO IN CHE????????????????????????
  • Kokushi
    Mark Strong in Body of Lies was great.
  • Maybe it's just me, but I thought Rosemarie DeWitt was the best part of Rachel Getting Married.
  • gah
    Seriously, Bill Irwin was amazing. I dunno why Jonathan Demme the director didnt get more credit. That was one of the most immersive movie experiences I've ever had. Felt like you were at the wedding.
  • Yeah def, 'Redbelt' was a great movie...and I was happy it didn't make MMA cheesy like some other movie I hated...
  • Tom
    Interesting list. Responding to your introduction, though: Eastwood was horrible in Gran Torino. His character was a ridiculous caricature, overplayed in nearly every scene. *growls* Even the best moments in that film came off forced.
  • Joe
    My personal vote would have to go to Sam Rockwell in Choke. Despite the budget and script problems, he still managed to make Vic Mancini a sympathetic character.
  • Slam that Shizz
    Yeah that guy in Redbelt was awesome along with the guy from Changeling. Word to your moms. I came to drop bombs.
  • I actually thought Rebecca Miller was better than Penelope Cruz in Vicky Christina Barcelona...but that opinion probably isn't shared.
  • Harsh. No Heath Ledger love?
blog comments powered by Disqus