Sundance Movie Review: Smart People

Smart People

Dennis Quaid plays Lawrence Wetherhold, a miserable and pompous college professor who suffers a head trauma while trying to jump the fence at a car impound lot. Unable to drive himself around, his screw-up adopted-brother Chuck (played by the incomparable Thomas Haden Church) moves in and becomes his personal chauffeur (if he can ever remember to pick his brother up). Chuck tries to expose Lawrence’s conservative daughter Vanessa (Ellen Page) to beer and drugs, and in the process, a complicated relationship develops. Meanwhile Lawrence falls for his Doctor Janet, played by the ever-so annoying Sarah Jessica Parker, and in the process, must find a way to cure himself of his unhealthy obsession with his deceased wife.

Page’s Vanessa is a snappy sarcastic smart aleck 17-year-old. Imagine if Juno were less indie/punk and more conservative / school smart. Page steals every scene she shares on screen. Church, also an attention hog (in a good way) is ever so charming as the lovable loser. Screenwriter Mark Poirier is all over Hollywood in a non-Diablo Cody way. Poirier is set to make his feature directing debut for Paramount with his script, Bong Hits 4 Jesus. Commercial turned Feature director Noam Murro makes a fantastic debut.

If there were one complaint about this film, it would be that the supporting storyline featuring the complicated relationship between Page and Church was far more interesting than the main romantic storyline. In fact, I would love to see a movie about those characters in that kind of situation, where more time could be devoted.

I must admit, I wasn’t expecting much from Smart People, but left the theater with a large grin in hand. This is a wonderful movie, not on the level of Juno, but up there next to Little Miss Sunshine.

/Film Rating:
8 out of 10

About the Author

Peter Sciretta is a film geek and popcultured fanboy living in San Francisco. He created /Film in 2005.

  • Granted, I am not at Sundance nor have I seen this film but the mere mention of Sarah Jessica Parker would be enough to keep me far, far away from this film. Maybe it was Sex and the City or maybe not but somewhere along the line her name alone induced reactions right up there with Melanie Griffth or Jennifer Lopez on the marquee. Who, in their infinite "Hollywood" wisdom, decided this woman could be anything less than nails on a chalkboard? I can hear the screeching right now. "The ever so annoying Sarah Jessica Parker", a truer statement has never been made.
  • $ J Money $
    Ellen Page marry me please?
  • The Addict
    Back off! She's mine!

    Now I'm uber upset to find out that Page is in this movie, since they were shooting on CMU campus and I'm always there. Had I only known *tear*
  • AMIT
    hi

    Sent from my mobile using FeedM8
  • Anonymous
    I'm saying this in jest, but it is kind of funny how consistently Peter has gone out of his way compare Juno to Little Miss Sunshine, saying that Juno was better, or just to prop up Juno in general. I get that way too sometimes about trying to tell people about something I like, but it can be laughable to see Peter continue to try to tell everyone how great Juno is.

    I've only met one person who absolutely loved Juno, with the rest mostly likely it or parts of it with a few reservations, though a few have said it was just mediocre (have yet to meet someone who's hated it). But out of that crowd, virtually all seemed to like Little Miss Sunshine more.
  • anon: Not to get sidetracked, this comment thread should be about Smart People and not Little Miss or Juno, but critically, Juno is on more top 10 lists and higher, more talks or oscar nominations, normal movie-goerwise, its going to easily exceed Sunshine's Box Office and those who have seen the movie have ranked it 8.4 out of 10 on imdb, compared to Sunshine's 8.1/10. I don't mean this as any sort of insult, but I think you and your friends are just in the minority. L

    Now lets get back to Smart People
  • Anonymous
    I could not agree more with Hooper X about how annoying Sarah Jessica Parker is. I can understand why some people like Sex & the City (though I loathe what I've seen of it), but I really don't understand SJP's appeal beyond that show. I don't mean to be mean, but I don't find her attractive or charming at all- and that's really what she seems to get by on, because it's not as if she is a serious actress.

    Everyone on the internet seems to have the uncanny ability to cite the past and hindsight is always 20/20, but I feel like people have been talking about Ellen Page for a while.... ever since Hard Candy, which even if people didn't see, there was a huge buzz about her. So, it's kind of absurd for people on the Oscar announcement shows this morning to say that with Juno she came "out of nowhere."

    And speaking of that.... Peter, I think it's splitting hairs to talk about the difference between an 8.4 and an 8.1 on IMDB or the 93% vs. 92% that is on Rotten Tomatoes. I think that when you compare the two, they did virtually the same with Oscar nominations and end of the year lists. The only difference you could really cite is the box office and, well, timing seems to be everything. Little Miss Sunshine came out in July and wasn't released and pushed right away as a possible awards contender.
  • $ J Money $
    anonymlus: I loved every second of it... seen it 3x


    Any word on any big companies picking it up? I wanna see it
  • Anonymous
    I'm not arguing that people liked it.

    I was arguing that, personal preference aside, it is absurd to try to categorize it as being in an entirely different league above Little Miss Sunshine.
blog comments powered by Disqus